Skip to main content

Full text of "Minnesota Small Craft Project Report"

See other formats


ERITAGE 

INNESOTA 


Ann  Merriman 


©2017 

Ann  Merriman,  Christopher  Olson,  and  Maritime  Heritage  Minnesota 


Jf\  c L E A N 
'(Smto  WATER 
LAND  & 
LEGACY 

AMENDMENT 


Project  Report 


RAMALEY  BOATS 


WORLD  FAMOUS  CHROME  FIBERCLAS 


_J_ 


Designers  and  Builders 

OF  ALL  KINDS  OF 

Pleasure  Craft 


Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works 


1 


Acknowledgments 

Maritime  Heritage  Minnesota  thanks  (MHM)  the  People  of  Minnesota  for  their  support  of 
the  Minnesota  Historical  and  Cultural  Heritage  Grant  program,  part  of  the  Clean  Water, 
Land  and  Legacy  Amendment;  without  the  MHCH  Grant  MHM  received  to  conduct  this 
work  the  project  would  not  have  gone  forward.  MHM  thanks  the  Grants  Office  of  the 
Minnesota  Historical  Society  for  their  efforts.  The  Minnesota  Small  Craft  Project  could 
not  have  been  completed  without  the  support  of  the  following:  MHM  Volunteer  Kelly 
Nehowig,  Mike  Worcester  and  Johanna  Ellison  (Cokato  Museum),  Dan  Cagley 
(Minnesota  Historical  Society),  Bob  Gasch  and  Judy  Sutherland  (West  Hennepin 
History  Center),  Scott  McGinnis,  Joan  Mooney  (Waseca  County  Historical  Society),  Don 
Knauff,  John  Nordby  (Minnesota  Department  of  Natural  Resources),  Paul  Petty,  Karrie 
Roeschlein  (City  of  Wahkon),  Gary  Vogesser,  and  the  Gale  Library  staff  at  the 
Minnesota  Historical  Society.  Lastly,  MHM  acknowledges  the  efforts  of  our  Board 
Members  Steven  R.  Hack,  Deb  Handschin,  and  Chair  Michael  F.  Kramer  for  their 
continued  support. 


MHM  Staff,  Volunteers,  Board  of  Trustees,  and  Mascots 


A,ohaeo\o9te' 


r Arofcae0' 


CvSrU'ovh* 


Volunteer  Otoer 

KetluNehoung 


Volunt, 


'eerDhj 


Did***" 


Stick 


volunteer  Diver 

Josh  Knutson 


Trustee 

S 


e\&on 


°‘b  ""><1*0 hin 


Ann 


Masoots  & Computing  Cats 

Peebles  Gat &Rodney  Oaf 


©2017 

Ann  Merriman,  Christopher  Olson,  and  Maritime  Heritage  Minnesota 

MHM  IS  A 501. (c). 3 NON-PROFIT  CORPORATION  DEDICATED  TO  THE  DOCUMENTATION,  CONSERVATION, 
AND  PRESERVATION  OF  MINNESOTA’S  FINITE  MARITIME  CULTURAL  RESOURCES 


2 


Introduction 

Maritime  Heritage  Minnesota  conducted  the  Minnesota  Small  Craft  Project  (MSC) 
between  February  and  April  2017.  The  purpose  of  the  Minnesota  Small  Craft  Project 
was  to  document,  3D  scan,  and  conduct  historical  research  of  5 Minnesota-produced 
small  boats  located  in  3 museum  collections.  MHM  chose  watercraft  constructed  by  the 
Ramaley  Boat  Company  of  Wayzata,  the  Indian  Post  Trading  Post  Boat  Company  of 
Vineland,  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  of  St.  Paul,  Cokato  Boat  Works  of  Cokato,  and 
Herter’s,  Inc.  of  Waseca. 


Research  Design  and  Methodology 

Several  Minnesota  museums  and  historical  societies  have  watercraft  in  their  collections, 
boats  that  were  constructed  in  the  state.  Often  the  general  public,  scholars,  and 
students  are  unaware  of  the  significance  of  small  and  seemingly  mundane  historic 
vessels  preserved  in  our  museums  and  historical  societies.  While  undertaking  research 
during  the  Minnesota  Dugout  Canoe  Project,  MHM  took  note  of  watercraft  on  exhibit 
and  in  storage  at  several  museums.  Drawing  upon  nautical  archaeological  and  historical 
knowledge  based  on  fieldwork  and  research,  MHM  chose  5 boats  to  investigate 
because  they  were  Minnesota-built,  rare,  and  relatively  unknown  in  the  maritime  history 
of  the  state.  MHM  received  permission  of  the  holding  institutions  to  3D  scan,  measure, 
draw,  and  photograph  5 boats:  Ramaley’s  Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boat,  Outboard 
Motor  Boats  from  the  Indian  Trading  Post,  Dingle,  and  Cokato  Boat  Works,  and  what 
was  thought  to  be  a Hudson  Bay  Model  boat  from  Herter’s.  The  3D  scanning  process  is 
a new  tool  MHM  has  utilized  since  late  2016  to  document  smaller  watercraft,  beginning 
with  the  Big  Swan  Dugout  Canoe  at  the  McLeod  County  Historical  Society.  Beyond  the 
actual  scanning  and  documentation  of  the  5 boats  during  the  MSC  Project,  another  of 
MHM’s  goal  was  to  determine  the  usefulness  of  the  inexpensive  scanning  technology 
chosen  for  the  work,  along  with  the  quality  of  its  output. 


MiKKesofca. 


rading  Post  Boat  Works 


oseph  Dingle  Boat  Works 


3 


The  Minnesota  Small  Craft  Project 

Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boat 

West  Hennepin  History  Center,  Long  Lake,  Hennepin  County 

History 

MHM  learned  of  the  existence  of  Fisherman’s  Friend  small  boats  in  the  early  2000s 
when  the  Minnesota  Transportation  Museum  took  custody  of  a 6-foot  long  example  of 
the  type.1  Research  conducted  for  Lake  Minnetonka  sonar  survey  and  nautical 
archaeological  projects  uncovered  a Ramaley  Boat  Company  of  Wayzata  brochure, 
dated  to  about  1913.  The  Ramaley  brochure  included  a Fisherman’s  Friend  row  boat  for 
sale.  John  Eugene  Ramaley  was  one  of  the  most  prolific  boat  builders  on  White  Bear 
Lake.  As  a young  man,  ‘Gene’  was  put  in  charge  of  the  sail  and  row  boat  fleet  owned  by 
his  father,  John  D.  Ramaley,  docked  at  Ramaley’s  Pavilion.  During  his  first  years 
working  at  the  Pavilion,  Gene  acquired  knowledge  of  boat  construction  - both  powered 
and  unpowered  - that  led  to  his  future  career  as  a boat  builder  and  captain.  Gene  and 
his  father  began  operating  the  steamer  Manitoba  in  late  May  1888  on  White  Bear  Lake. 
In  1891,  with  the  experience  gained  from  maintaining  Manitoba  and  his  father’s  fleet  of 
recreational  boats,  Gene  designed  and  built  his  first  two  yachts,  Bird  and  Shadow.  In 
1895  Gene  founded  Ramaley  Boat  Company  in  a small  barn,  and  then  constructed  a 
much  larger  shop  on  the  lake  in  Cottage  Park  in  1899.  The  elder  Ramaley  was  one  of 
the  boat  company’s  customers  as  well  when  Gene  built  a new  launch  for  his  father  in 
late  May  1899.  Gene  also  constructed  and  ran  his  own  steamers  White  Bear  and 
Wildwood  beginning  in  1900  and  1901.  By  1912  the  business  was  called  the  Ramaley 
Boat  Building  and  Navigation  Company.  In  that  year,  Ramaley  purchased  the  Moore 
Boat  Works  on  Lake  Minnetonka  in  Wayzata,  reportedly  for  $20,000.  Ramaley 
continued  operations  on  both  White  Bear  Lake  and  Lake  Minnetonka  until  1925  when 
the  entire  boat-building  enterprise  was  shifted  to  Wayzata.  In  1929,  Walker  Boat  Works, 
Wise  Boat  Works,  and  the  Ramaley  Boat  Company  combined  to  become  the 
Minnetonka  Boat  Works  in  Wayzata  (Castle  1912,  964;  Lake  Breeze,  1888a-c; 
McGinnis  2010,  302;  Minnetonka  Herald,  1954;  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1891a,d;  Vadnais 
2004,  102;  Wayzata  Reporter  1912;  White  Bear  Life  1900,  1901a-b). 


Left:  Moore  Boat  Works  in  1912,  the  same  year  the  company  was  sold  to  Ramaley  Boat  Company  (Sanborn 

Map  Company  1904,  711). 

Right:  1919  Ramaley  Boat  Company  advertisement  (Hennepin  County  Herald  1919,  digitized  by  MHM). 


This  small  wreck  was  illegally  raised  from  the  bottom  of  Lake  Minnetonka’s  Wayzata  Bay  sometime  prior  to  2000. 


4 


Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boat 

MHM  documented  the  Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boat  (FFRB)  housed  at  the  West 
Hennepin  History  Center  (WHHC)  on  February  20,  2017.  The  FFRB  derives  its  name 
from  the  model  of  small  row  boat  produced  by  the  Ramaley  Boat  Company  in  1913  or 
later  at  its  Wayzata  location  on  Lake  Minnetonka.  The  FFRB’s  wooden  hull  is  13.75  feet 
long,  4.00  feet  in  the  beam,  with  a 12-inch  depth  of  hold.  The  boat’s  flat  bottom  is 
athwartships  planked  - a diagnostic  attribute  for  the  Fisherman's  Friend  design.  Both 
the  port  and  starboard  sides  consist  of  one  wide  strake  - a plank  - along  with  a thinner 
gunwale  plank  with  an  attached  rubrail.  The  boat’s  side  planks  are  joined  end  to  end, 
making  it  carvel-built.  The  stem  consists  of  a rounded  stempost  attached  to  the  keel 
with  a triangular  sampson  post  attached  to  the  inner  surface  that  extends  vertically 
above  the  gunwale.  The  sampson  post  has  a hole  bored  through  it  that  served  as  a 
towing  ring  and  possibly  has  an  attachment  point  for  a forestay.  Forward,  the  keel  is  a 
single  flat,  narrow  beam  while  at  the  stern,  it  is  a two-piece  beam  that  extends 
significantly  below  the  boat’s  bottom  forming  a skeg.  The  square  transom,  like  the 
boat’s  sides,  is  comprised  of  one  wide  strake  topped  with  a narrower  gunwale  plank 
whose  ends  are  angled  downward  to  meet  the  port  and  starboard  gunwale  and  rubrail. 
An  unpainted  vertical  section  on  the  transom  marks  the  former  location  of  the  missing 
stempost.  The  FFRB  has  three  bench  seats,  held  up  by  short  braces  attached  to  the 
inner  hull;  the  stern  seat  is  missing  along  with  the  port  side  brace.  A set  of  oarlock  holes 
were  bored  vertically  into  the  gunwale  just  aft  of  the  amidships  bench  and  two  metal 
straps  attached  to  the  boat’s  floor  planks  are  remnants  of  the  rower’s  foot  braces.  It  is 
unknown  if  the  braces  consisted  of  individual  pads  or  a metal  or  wood  bar  that  would 
slide  under  the  straps.  The  FFRB  is  held  together  entirely  with  nails,  not  screws. 


The  Fisherman’s  Friend  (MHM). 


5 


The  Fisherman’s  Friend  in  the  Ramaley  Boat  Company's  brochure  around  1913  ( Ramaley  Boat 

Company- 1913,  digitized  by  MHM). 

Ramaley  Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boats  were  advertised  to  be  14.00  feet  long,  46.00 
inches  in  the  beam  (3.83  feet),  and  a 14-inch  depth  of  hold,  although  a 16.00  model  was 
offered  as  well  (Ramaley  Boat  Company~1913).  MHM  contends  the  nearly  identical 
measurements  of  the  FFRB  depicted  in  Ramaley’s  brochure  - and  the  habit  of  rounding 
up  numbers  in  catalogs  and  brochures  - clearly  suggests  the  boat  housed  at  the  WHHC 
was  constructed  by  the  Ramaley  Boat  Company  in  Wayzata  after  1913.  In  addition  to 
the  FFRB  in  the  collection  of  the  WHHC,  two  Fisherman’s  Friend  wrecks  have  been 
identified  on  the  bottom  of  Lake  Minnetonka.  The  Fisherman's  Friend  Wreck  1 (21  -HE- 
485)  is  12.80  feet  long,  2.80  feet  wide,  with  a 1.40-foot  depth  of  hold.  The  wreck  is 
capsized  and  lying  with  its  flat  athwartships-planked  bottom  exposed;  the  wreck  has  no 
surviving  keel  plank.  The  bow  is  sharply  pointed  and  the  stern  has  a square  transom 
design.  The  wreck  is  constructed  of  three  strakes  on  each  side  with  a rubrail  attached  to 
the  top-most  strake  on  port,  starboard,  and  the  square  transom  as  well.  The 
Fisherman's  Friend  Wreck  2 (21-HE-489)  is  15.00  feet  long,  3.20  feet  wide,  with  a 
12.00-inch  depth  of  hold  at  the  stern.  The  wreck's  bow  would  have  been  pointed,  but 


6 


only  the  stempost  with  two  hull  plank  fragments  attached  to  it  survive,  but  are  detached 
from  the  wreck.  The  hull  is  carvel-built,  it  has  a square  stern,  and  a flat  athwartships- 
planked  bottom  that  is  a diagnostic  attribute  for  the  Fisherman's  Friend  design.  Although 
the  wreck  is  profusely  covered  in  zebra  mussels,  a small  section  of  exposed  hull 
indicates  it  is  painted  white.  A large  rock  sits  in  the  wreck  at  the  stern,  indicating  the 
wreck  was  likely  scuttled  (Merriman  and  Olson  2015,  7-10,  2016,  6-8). 


Above:  Ole  Backlund  painting  his 
Fisherman’s  Friend  on  Lake 
Minnetonka  prior  to  Spring  launch  in 
May  1937  (MNHS  Qv1.2r8,  digitized 
by  MHM). 


Left:  A sketch  of  the  Fisherman’s 
Friend  Wreck  2 (21-HE-489, 
Christopher  Olson)  and  the  capsized 
Fisherman’s  Friend  Wreck  1 (21  -HE- 
485,  Mark  Slick). 


Using  a Fisherman’s  Friend  guarantees  great  results  during  your  fishing  excursion,  if  you  can  get  them 
in  the  boat  (Left:  1918  Postcard;  Right:  Postcard,  Courtesy  of  Bob  Gasch). 


7 


The  two  Fisherman’s  Friend  Wrecks  and  the  Ramaley-advertised  version  of  the  vessel, 
while  not  identical  to  the  FFRB,  are  the  same  design.  The  FFRB  lacks  diagnostic 
attributes  that  are  defined  by  a calendar  date,  such  as  the  presence  of  slot-head  or 
Phillips  head  woodscrews.  The  boat  is  held  together  entirely  by  nails  and  in  some 
places,  abundant  numbers  of  them.  MHM  suggests  a FFRB  construction  date  of  the 
1920s.  The  Fisherman’s  Friend  Row  Boat’s  condition  is  dependent  on  a stable 
environment  with  an  appropriate  relative  humidity  level  near  65%.  The  vessel  has 
begun  to  warp,  but  this  will  cease  - but  not  be  reversed  - if  it  is  allowed  to  rest  on  a 
stable  flat  base,  with  support  along  the  bottom  on  either  side  of  the  keel. 


8 


Examples  of  Ramaley  Boat  Company  Vessels 

(See  McGinnins  2010  for  information  on  many  Ramaley  boats  on  Lake  Minnetonka). 


ramaley  row  BOATS 

* Imt  Wwta), *n<i,our^lve  studied  the  requirement*  of  careful  t 

I "r  position  to  build  It  ^ ^ money  and  stall,  & 


RAMALEY 


WAYZATA.  MINN. 


MINNETONKA  STOCK  MODEL 


special  hshing 


COMMNAJS?. 


bear,  MODEL  36 


HUNTING  AND  FISHING  BOATS 


Y DE  LUXE  ROW  BOAT 


■S&F 


-1913  Ramaley  Boat  Company 
Brochure  (MNHS,  digitized  by  MHM) 
White  Bear  Model  36  is  remarkably 
similar  to  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works 
Outboard  Motor  Boat  (see  page  21). 


"J  RAMALEY  DETACHABLE  STOCK  MOTOR  ROW  BOATS 


The  Ramaley  Family  Motor  Boat  (Ramaley  Boat  Company  1911)  and  the  Ramaley  Family  Motor  Boat 

Wreck  (21-HE-490)  in  Lake  Minnetonka. 


■ 


9 


Indian  Trading  Post  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (1996.250.1) 
Minnesota  Historical  Society,  St.  Paul,  Ramsey  County 


History 

MHM  first  learned  of  the  Indian  Trading  Post  Boat  Works  (ITPBW)  on  Lake  Mille  Lacs 
when  visiting  the  Minnesota  Historical  Society  (MNHS)  warehouse  in  January  2014.2 
The  ITPBW,  established  in  May  1929,  was  a subsidiary  of  the  Mille  Lacs  Trading  Post 
owned  by  Harry  and  Jeannette  Ayer.  It  was  reported  that  the  “Indian  Trading  Post  has  a 
new  boat  factory,  having  purchased  the  Lucus  boat  works  in  Wahkon”.  The  ITPBW  was 
located  on  the  grounds  of  the  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post;  apparently  Ayer 
purchased  the  Lucus  firm’s  equipment  and  re-located  it  to  Vineland.  By  the  end  of  May 
1929,  boatbuilding  was  in  full  swing  and  the  company  advertised  in  a local  paper  and 
invited  readers  to  “visit  our  new  factory,  and  see  them  under  construction”.  The 
enterprise  employed  only  Mille  Lacs  Band  of  Ojibwe  members  and  within  a few  years  of 
its  founding,  the  ITPBW  was  touted  as  a success  in  the  region.  This  enterprise 
employed  18  men  to  construct  and  operate  boats  for  the  Post’s  tourist  fishing 
excursions,  and  for  sale  to  the  general  public  (Brainerd  Daily  Dispatch  1929,  1933;  Mille 
Lacs  Messenger  1929;  MNHS  Finding  Aid,  ND). 


An  aerial  view  of  the  Indian  Trading 
Post  Boat  Works  on  Lake  Mille  Lacs 
(John  R.  Borchert  Map  Library,  17 
September  1939). 


. ■ ■■ 

■ 

f 

:•  Y».  M-  i 

i*  f 'c.  h. 


znnz 


Right:  Ayer 
promoted  the 
Indian  Trading 
Post  Boat  Works 
in  the  local 
paper  (Mille 
Lacs  Messenger 
1929). 


Indian  Trading  Post 

BOATS 

■ T ;[  - • ■ v . • !/  • 

Built  from  quality  material  for  years  of  service. 
Designed  for  safety  and  seaworthiness,  ease  in 
4 handling,  sturdiness,  style  and  comfort. 
Available  in  various  sizes  and  models  for  outboard 
motors,  livery,  pleasure  or  family  iise. 
Visit  our  new  factory,-  and  see  them  under  con- 
struction. 

Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post 

. | Highway  No.  18 

Postoffice — Onamia,  Minn. 


2MHM  was  at  the  MNHS  to  document  and  take  a wood  sample  from  a dugout  canoe  for  the  Minnesota  Dugout  Canoe  Project. 


10 


Z*«44 


Richard  Skinaway 


Jim  Hanks,  Sr 


The  employees  of  the  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works 
constructing  wooden  boats  in  their 
fully  equipped  workshop  in  March 
1931  (MNHS  HE5.4p56, 
HE5.4p16  HE5.4p17,  HE5.4p13, 
HE5.4p22,  HE5.4p14,  digitized  by 
MHM). 


Jim  Hanks,  Sr,  Joe  Eagle,  Unknown 


Jim  Hanks,  Sr 


Mr.  Fairbanks 


11 


In  November  1991,  former  Trading  Post  employees  Fred  B.  Benjamin,  Letitia  B. 
Caldwell,  Maude  Kegg,  Sally  Mitchell,  and  Batiste  Sam  remembered  people  and 
activities  associated  with  the  Boat  Works  in  the  late  1920s-late  1930s  in  oral  interviews. 
The  boat  factory  itself  was  “a  big  barn-like  building  with  high  front  steps”.  “All  the 
boatmaking  equipment  was  there. ..They  just  worked  on  the  ground  floor.. .then  probably 
boats  were  stored  above. ..The  boat  factory  wasn’t  in  operation  during  the  winter.. .Mr. 
Blythe  at  one  time  was  the  overseer... Then  Mr.  Fairbanks  was  sort  of  a straw  boss”. 
The  boats  constructed  in  the  factory  were  described  as  “all  strip-bottom  boats.  That  I 
remember  from  the  advertising. ..some  were  rowboats,  and  some  were 
motorboats... they  had  a few  twelve,  not  many  - but  fourteen,  sixteen,  eighteen  and  a 
few  twenties.  Mostly  I guess  the  twenties  came  by  order,  but  the  popular  sizes  were 
fourteen  and  sixteen. ..Mr.  Ayer  kept  fifty-six  [boats]. ..for  the  resort  use.  Well,  with 
twenty-six  cabins  and  fifty-six  fishing  boats,  we  were  so  crammed  every  May 


12 


fifteenth... [for]  the  walleye  fishing  season”  (Caldwell  1991,  37,  42-43;  Mitchell  1991,  42- 
43). 


Tourist  fishermen  at  the  Indian  Trading  Post  Boat  Works  dock,  utilizig  Post  boats  for  fishing  excursions 

(MNHS  GV3.33r63,  digitized  by  MHM). 

The  interviewees  recalled  the  names  of  several  Ojibwe  boat  builders  over  the  years: 
Joe  Eagle,  Sam  Mitchell,  Gene  Mitchell,  Jim  Mitchell,  Jim  Hanks,  Sr.,  Jim  Hanks,  Jr., 
Dick  Skinaway,  and  Dick  Garbow/Gahbow.  Further,  it  was  revealed  that  some  of  the 
builders  also  served  as  fishing  guides  and  pilots.  Fred  Benjamin  remembered  “They  had 
a great  big  dock  too.  That’s  where  all  the  boats  [were]  used.  All  those  Indians  used  to 
go  do  the  pilot  on  the  motors  and  take  tourists  to  the  better  fishing.... I didn’t  see  any 
non-Indian  driving  a motor.  They  never  had  no  accident.  Every  time  there’s  a storm, 
Indians  know  exactly  when  the  storm’s  gonna  go.  They  didn’t  want  to  go.  They  didn’t 
want  to  take  anybody  out”.  Maude  Kegg  stated  “The  Indian  guys  were  making  the 
boats,  and  there  used  to  be  a guide  here... four-five-six-seven  of  them.  They  - those 
guys  would  take  them  [the  tourists]  to  wherever  they  could  fish.  They’d  know  the  reefs 
and  where  the  fish  bites,  I suppose,  so  they  had  guides  like  that”.  More  than  one 
interviewee  remembered  the  ‘trading  post  fleet’  comprised  of  tourists  in  rented  fishing 
boats  and  a towboat,  operated  by  a guide  or  pilot:  “He  [Ayers]  had  a whole  fleet  when  I 
was  here...there’d  be  a motor  on  one  and  a pilot  and  tow  line  for  all  the  others.  Maybe 
they’d  take  out  eight  or  ten  boats  on  one  tow  line”.  “I  know  my  dad  used  to  work  there. 
He  used  to  take  the  fishermen  way  down  to  the  point  with  a motor  boat.  He  hooked  the 
boats  with  the  fisherman  in  and  then  takes  them  over  to  the  point... he  was  a guide  for 
the  fishermens. ...[his  name  was]  Dick...Gahbow”  (Benjamin  1991,  6;  Kegg  1991,  15; 
Mitchell  1 991 , 39,  43;  Sam  1 991 , 3,  42  44). 


13 


Lloyd  Blithe, 
Unknown,  Jim 
Hanks,  Sr,  Mr. 
Fairbanks,  Joe 
Eagle,  Richard 
Garbow/Gahbow, 
Leticia  (Daly) 
Caldwell  in  truck 
(MNHS  HE5.4p1 1 , 
digitized  by  MHM) 


Jim  Hanks,  Jr, 
Richard  Skinaway, 
Jim  Hanks,  Sr, 
Jim  Mitchell 
(MNHS  HE5.4p20, 
digitized  by  MHM) 


Leticia  (Daly)  Caldwell  and  the  crew  (MNHS  HE5.4r21,  digitized  by  MHM). 


14 


Letitia  Caldwell  supplied  a colorful  description  of  the  ‘fleet’:  “They’d  hook  one  boat 
behind  the  other,  and  this  long  train  of  boats.  They’d  hook  one  boat  behind  the  other, 
and  this  long  train  of  boats  would  be  going  out  around  the  point  from  the  bay.  Old 
Moqua  would  take  out  sixteen-twenty  boats  at  a time. ..[a]  long  string  chugging  along 
behind  the  one  motor  boat  that  they  used.  Old  Moqua  would  be  taking  them  out  there, 
and  he’d  take  them  way  around  the  point,  out  of  sight  of  the  store.  In  the  evening  he’d 
go  back  and  get  them.  They  just  had  to  stay  out  there  all  day,  unless  they  wanted  to  row 
back.  I can  still  see  those  trains  of  boats,  like  a bunch  of  little  ducks”  (Caldwell  1991, 
38). 


Sally  Mitchell  described  one  strong  Lake  Mille  Lacs  wind  storm  and  its  affect  on  the 
Trading  Post  Fleet’  and  boaters:  “My  brother  was  working  down  at  Lakeside  Inn.  It  was 
very  very  windy  - a terrific  windstorm.  They  had  taken  boats  out  from  down  there,  and 
our  boats  had  gone  out  from  here  [the  Trading  Post],  Ours  had  come  back  in.  My 


15 


brother  was  in  one  of  the  boats  from  down  at  Lakeside  Inn,  and  his  boat  broke  loose. 
He  was  in  the  last  boat.  It  had  broken  loose  from  the  line  of  them.  He  had  not  an  oar,  a 
paddle  or  anything  in  the  boat,  and  he  was  just  set  adrift.  From  the  gentleman  who  had 
the  lead  boat  with  the  motor  on  it  tried  to  turn,  but  the  other  boat  was  moving  faster  than 
he  could  get  back  to  it.  Se  he  went  on  in  and  told  them  that  there  was  a boat  adrift  with 
a man  in  it.  They  called  up  here.  There  was  one  of  the  Indian  boys,  Johnny  Door,  was 
here.  He  said  he’d  take  a boat  out.  He  took  a boat  out  from  here  and  went  out  and  got 
my  brother’s  boat  and  towed  it  in.  My  brother  was  sick  for  the  rest  of  the  day,  really 
honestly  seasick.  That  was  quite  a rescue”  (Mitchell  1991 , 53). 

Ayer  stored  the  fishing  boats  on  site  during  the  winter.  Apparently  the  factory  ceased 
producing  boats  in  1939  and  the  building  was  torn  down  sometime  around  1940.  Fred 
Benjamin  believed  the  main  reason  for  the  demise  of  the  boat  works  was  ’’The  man  that 
did  a lot  of  boat  work.. .he  passed  away.  So  it  kind  of  got  [shut]  down. ..That  was  Hanks, 
Jim  Hanks”.  It  was  believed  that  no  examples  of  watercraft  produced  by  the  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works  craftsmen  survived,  that  they  simply  rotted  away  or  were 
burned  to  dispose  of  them.  However,  MNHS  records  stipulate  that  Ayer  sold  the  boat 
works  to  the  US  Department  of  the  Interior  in  1939;  whether  the  factory  continued  to 
produce  watercraft  or  was  torn  down  at  that  time  is  unknown.  In  the  end,  the  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works  reportedly  constructed  200  boats  from  1929-1939  - (Benjamin 
1991,  4,  6;  MNHS  Timeline ; Waymarking  2013)  with  only  one  confirmed  example 
surviving.3 

Indian  Trading  Post  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat 

MHM  documented  the  ITPBW  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (IOMB)  on  February  8 and  17  and 
March  1,  8,  and  10,  2017  at  the  MNHS  warehouse.  The  lOMB’s  wooden  hull  is  17.25 
feet  long,  3.75  feet  in  the  beam,  with  a 21.00-inch  depth  of  hold.  The  stem  consists  of  a 
triangular  outer  stempost  that  is  curved  and  attached  to  the  keel.  Large  bolts  driven 
through  the  outer  stempost  attach  it  to  the  inner  stempost  (not  seen).  A U-shaped  metal 
bracket  attached  to  the  outer  hull  goes  through  the  strakes  and  the  inner  stempost;  it 
holds  a tow  ring.  At  the  stern,  the  keel  protrudes  from  the  hull  bottom  and  is  rectangular 
in  cross-section.  The  gunwale  of  the  IOMB  is  intact,  although  it  is  damaged  from  age 
and  lack  of  maintenance.  The  lack  of  a caprail  exposes  the  futtocks  between  the  beams 
that  comprise  the  gunwale.  A thin  rubrail  is  complete  and  attached  to  the  port  and 
starboard  gunwales  along  the  entire  length  of  the  boat,  attached  with  slot-head  screws. 
Further,  on  the  port  side  of  the  boat  10.33  feet  from  the  bow,  a hull  break  extends  from 
the  gunwale  to  the  turn  of  the  bilge.  Along  the  bilge  turn,  the  strakes  have  separated 
and  the  aft  portion  of  the  hull  angles  inward  and  the  forward  portion  of  the  hull  angles 
outward.  The  hull  consists  of  thin  wooden  strip  strakes  joined  end  to  end,  making  it 
carvel-built.  The  substantial  cambered  foredeck  is  constructed  of  slightly  wider  strip 
planks  than  those  that  comprised  the  hull’s  sides  and  bottom.4  The  aft  edge  of  the 
foredeck  is  shaped  by  coaming  that  extends  down  each  side  of  the  boat.  The  square 
transom,  designed  to  take  an  outboard  motor,  is  comprised  of  2 wide  1 .75-inch  thick 
planks  attached  to  the  gunwale  with  slot-head  wood  screws. 


3Ojibwe  artist  Terry  Kemper  informed  MHM  that  another  ITPBW  vessel  may  survive  in  Florida;  MHM  hopes  this  is  the  case 
(personal  communication,  24  February  2017). 

4A  damaged  area  on  the  foredeck  suggests  the  boat  may  have  had  a navigation  light  that  is  now  missing.  MHM  contends  the 
wood  was  damaged  by  an  object  sitting  on  the  deck  for  many  years  in  uncontrolled  conditions,  not  by  fittings. 


16 


The  10MB  has  a wide  flat  bottom,  a design  necessary  for  stability  and  safety  on  Lake 
Mille  Lacs.  The  aft  section  of  the  boat  has  clear  tumblehome,  where  the  hull  narrows 
noticeably  from  the  waterline  to  the  gunwale.  Inside  the  hull  at  the  transom,  a centerline 
knee  - attached  to  the  exposed  keel  (the  boat  does  not  have  a keelson)  and  the 
transom  with  substantial  bolts  - adds  a significant  support  to  the  stern  to  accommodate 
the  outboard  motor.  Two  horizontal  knees  on  the  port  and  starboard  quarters  at 
gunwale  level  also  add  stability  and  strength;  vertical  beams  attached  flush  to  the 
transom  support  these  knees.  The  IOMB  has  thin  frames  attached  to  the  inner  hull, 
providing  rigidity  to  the  vessel.  With  the  exception  of  the  3 aft-most  frames  that  are 
interrupted  by  the  stern  knee,  each  frame  is  one  long  thin  piece  of  wood  that  has  been 
curved  into  a wide  U shape,  attached  to  the  hull  using  short  nails.  Further,  on  top  of 
every  second  floor  (with  the  exception  of  the  first  2 at  the  stern),  a rider  beam  was 
attached  to  provide  support  for  a deck.  Triangular  wedges  removed  from  the  bottom 
edge  of  the  riders  served  as  limber  holes,  designed  to  channel  bilge  water  to  the  stern 
for  later  draining.  Longitudinal  stringers  attached  to  the  futtocks  on  both  sides  extend 
from  the  stern  quarters  to  under  the  foredeck,  stopping  at  2 riders  attached  to  futtocks. 
Attached  to  the  aft  face  of  the  futtock  riders,  an  athwartships  brace  extends  from  port  to 
starboard;  2 thin  stanchions  connected  to  the  brace  serve  as  supports  for  the  foredeck. 
With  the  exception  of  the  construction  details  previously  described  as  attached  by  bolts 
or  slot-head  screws,  the  vessel  is  held  together  with  small  nails.  At  the  bow,  a double 
row  of  nails  attach  the  strakes  to  the  stempost  and  at  the  stern,  double  rows  of  nails 
attach  the  strakes  to  the  edge  of  the  transom.  Little  paint  survives  on  the  outer  hull,  but 
traces  of  white  primer  are  extant,  as  well  as  mustard  yellow  and  dark  green  paint.  The 


17 


green  paint  primarily  appears  at  the  bow  and  transom  under  the  waterline;  the  yellow 
paint  is  found  higher  on  the  bow  and  transom  up  the  tumblehome,  and  on  the  hull’s 
sides. 


Historic  early-1930s  photographs  of  finished  products  of  the  Indian  Trading  Post  Boat 
Works  indicate  slight  design  differences  when  compared  to  the  IOMB,  some  of  them 
apparently  related  to  the  vessel’s  size.  Images  of  rowboats,  lighter  vessels  with  less 
freeboard,  have  bench  seats  incorporated  into  their  construction.  There  are  no 
indications  of  benches  or  other  seating  evident  in  the  IOMB,  nor  is  there  evidence  of  a 
deck  that  would  have  rested  on  the  floor  riders.  However,  for  the  IOMB  to  function  as  a 
guide  and  towboat  for  the  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  tourist  fishing  enterprise,  a 
personal  watercraft,  or  as  a US  Forestry  Service  vessel,  it  must  have  had  benches  or 
seats  of  an  undetermined  design.  Further,  the  steering  mechanism  has  not  survived  in 
the  IOMB,  and  no  pictorial  evidence  of  the  gear  has  been  located.  Outboard  motors  in 
the  1930s  were  primarily  directly  steered  using  attached  tillers.  However,  remote 
steering  using  cables  and  a steering  wheel  was  possible,  but  the  system  cannot  be 
determined  with  the  surviving  evidence.  Images  of  ITPBW  vessels  that  appear  to  be 
similar  in  size  and  design  to  the  IOMB  differ  in  superficial  details,  such  as  the  presence 
of  aft  splashrails  that  were  never  incorporated  into  the  construction  of  the  IOMB. 
Further,  the  IOMB  coaming  and  accompanying  caprail  may  have  extended  around  the 
entirety  of  the  vessel’s  cockpit  when  it  was  constructed,  but  did  not  survive,  thus  making 
the  futtock  ends  visible  at  the  gunwale.  A wreck  similar  to  the  IOMB  has  been  identified 
on  the  bottom  of  Lake  Minnetonka.  The  Wooden  Outboard  Utility  Wreck  (21-HE-491)  is 
14.00  feet  long,  3.90  feet  in  the  beam,  and  3.60  feet  at  the  square  stern  with  a slightly 
cambered  foredeck.  The  differences  between  the  IOMB  and  21-HE-491  - beyond  their 
sizes  - are  the  athwartships  planking  of  the  foredeck,  the  wide  caprail  from  the  bow  to 
the  stern  on  both  sides  boat,  and  splashrails  that  extend  along  the  entirety  of  the  outer 
hull  from  bow  to  stern  on  port  and  starboard  (Merriman  and  Olson  2016,  15-17). 


18 


The  Wooden 
Outboard  Utility 
Wreck  (21-HE-491) 
on  the  bottom  of 
Lake  Minnetonka 
(Kelly  Nehowig). 


19 


(MNHS  HE5.4p54,  HE5.4p59,  HE5.4r15,  HE5.4M4,  digitized  by  MHM) 

The  Indian  Trading  Post  Outboard  Motor  Boat  is  in  stable  condition  and  its  continued 
health  is  dependent  on  a stable  environment  with  an  appropriate  humidity  level.  The 
obvious  checking  along  the  boat’s  rubrail  and  gunwale  is  a clear  indicator  of 
inappropriate  storage  for  decades  in  the  past.  The  port  side  hull  damage,  while 
appearing  rather  drastic,  is  not  currently  having  an  adverse  affect  on  the  boat;  no  stress 
is  being  applied  to  the  area,  nor  is  the  boat’s  own  weight  affecting  stability  at  that  point. 
On  the  whole,  the  vessel  as  it  is  currently  stored  with  support  to  the  bottom  of  the  hull,  is 
sufficient  to  sustain  the  watercraft’s  current  condition. 


MHM’s  3D  scans  of  the  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works  Outboard 
Motor  Boat.  The  scanning  process 
included  several  scans  saved  as 
separate  files.  Because  of  the 
vagaries  in  lighting,  the  color 
version  of  the  scanned  images 
appears  like  a patchwork  (left). 


20 


21 


Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (2004.82. 1.A-F) 

Minnesota  Historical  Society,  St.  Paul,  Ramsey  County 

History 

MHM  first  learned  of  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (DOMB)  when 
visiting  the  Minnesota  Historical  Society  (MNHS)  warehouse  in  January  2014.5  Joseph 
Dingle  founded  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  in  1880.  However,  Dingle  was  already 
“quite  well  known  as  a boat  builder,  and  has  built  row  and  sail  boats  for  most  of  the  lake 
resorts  of  Minnesota.  One  of  his  recent  orders  was  for  a row  boat  for  Hon.  C.  F. 
McDonald,  of  St.  Cloud”  by  March  of  that  year.  A large  1879  advertisement  supports  the 
contention  that  Dingle  was  a boat-builder  prior  to  the  recognized  establishment  of  the 
firm  in  1880:  Dingle  manufactured  “pleasure  boats,  sail  yachts,  hunting  boats  and 
catamarans.  Oars  and  boat  fixtures  always  on  hand.  Repairing  neatly  and  promptly 
done”.  The  Boat  Works  was  located  at  421  Clinton  Avenue.  The  Dingle  family  resided  at 
121  Isabel  Street  East  - and  conducted  company  paperwork  in  the  home  - just  to  the 
south  of  the  workshop  in  West  St.  Paul.  Today  that  intersection  is  in  St.  Paul  proper. 
The  house  was  situated  on  the  eastern  portions  of  lots  6 and  7 in  section  37  and  the 
Boat  Works  occupied  the  eastern  portion  of  lot  8 on  Clinton  Avenue.  St.  Paul  Fire 
Station  No.  6 (1884-1965)  was  also  located  in  section  37  next  to  the  Boat  Works,  with 
an  address  of  126  Delos  Street  East  (Legeros  2013;  Polk  and  Weeks  1879,  xvi,  167, 
498;  Sanborn  Map  Company  1904,  619;  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1880,  1885a-b). 


The  location  of  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  on  Clinton  Avenue  between  Isabel  and  Delos  Streets 
(Sanborn  Map  Company  1904,  620)  and  an  early  company  advertisement  (Polk  and  Weeks  1879,  xvi). 


5MHM  was  at  the  MNHS  to  document  and  take  a wood  sample  from  a dugout  canoe  for  the  Minnesota  Dugout  Canoe  Project. 


22 


Insight  into  the  workings  of  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  is  found  in  several  historical 
sources  during  the  late  19th  into  the  first  half  of  the  20th  Century.  In  1895,  the  ‘family 
business’  nature  of  the  factory  is  evident  since  Joseph,  along  with  two  of  his  sons  Albert 
and  Fred,  were  engaged  in  boat  building  for  the  company.  In  1904,  the  Dingle  factory 
advertised  to  hire  “Boat  Carpenters  at  Once;  first-class  wages”  to  assist  the  family  of 
boatwrights.  In  1905,  Joseph  and  sons  Albert,  Fred,  John,  and  Harry  worked  in  the 
factory  while  son  John  worked  as  the  Boat  Works’  clerk.  Further,  in  1914,  six  of  Dingle’s 
sons  worked  for  the  firm:  Charles  (foreman),  Fred  (manager),  Harry  (builder),  John 
(salesman),  Richard  (builder),  and  Roy  (builder).6  Additionally,  Otto  H.  Halbe  built  boats 
for  Dingle  that  year.  Also  in  1914,  Fred  - “better  known  as  Dingle  Dongle  Dingle”  in  the 
“Men  We  All  Know”  column  of  Power  Boating  magazine  - represented  the  Boat  Works 
during  an  inspection  of  the  Loew-Victor  Engine  Company  in  Chicago.  By  1920,  another 
aspect  of  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  business  was  its  qualification  as  the  only 
Evinrude  detachable  motor  service  station  in  Minnesota;  with  the  early  popularity  of 
small  Evinrude  outboard  motors,  this  service  was  valuable  to  small  boat  owners  in  the 
state.  Also  in  1920,  Fred  Dingle’s  attendance  at  New  York’s  16th  Motor  Boat  Show  as 
part  of  the  St.  Paul  Motor  Boat  Club’s  delegation  was  noted,  as  the  group  perused  new 
offerings  for  the  next  boating  season.  The  reputation  and  influence  of  the  Boat  Works 
and  the  Dingle  Family  boatwrights  was  evident  when  the  Sterling  Engine  Company 
associated  the  company  with  significant  North  American  building  firms  in  a 1923  ad, 
among  them:  Herreshoff  Boat  Works  of  Bristol,  Rl,  George  Lawley  and  Son  of  Boston, 
Albany  Boat  Corporation  of  Waterliet,  NY,  Red  Bank  Yacht  Works,  Red  Bank,  NJ,  and 
Ditchburn  Boats,  Muskoka,  Ontario  (Judson,  Jr.  1920,  20;  Minneapolis  Journal  1904a; 
Minnesota,  Ramsey  County  1895,  268,  1905,  Sheet  32;  Motor  Boat  1920,  42;  Motor 
Boating  1923,  133;  Polk  1914,  542,  750;  Power  Boating  1914,  82). 

Throughout  the  1880s,  Joseph  Dingle  and  his  company’s  daily  operation  and 
accomplishments  are  chronicled  through  historical  documents.  In  late  April  1881, 
“Amphibious  Globe  Reporters”  told  the  story  of  a Mississippi  River  flood  and  with  it,  high 
winds  that  threatened  the  city.  It  was  reported  “Yesterday  morning  the  chief  of  police 
took  possession  of  half  a dozen  boats  belonging  to  Joseph  Dingle,  and  placed  them  at 
the  disposal  of  the  police  patrol.  They  proved  to  be  of  great  service  during  the  day.”  The 
City  of  St.  Paul  reimbursed  the  Boat  Works  $280.00  (Order  12317)  for  using  the  boats 
in  what  was  termed  “6th  Ward  Relief.  On  White  Bear  Lake,  “Mr.  Dingle’s  boats  are  well 
managed  and  the  fishing  on  the  Mahtomedi  side,  on  account  of  the  depth  of  water,  is 
the  best  in  the  lake”  (City  Comptroller  1886;  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1881,  1883).  These 
insights  into  Joseph  Dingle’s  business  - apparently  he  kept  an  inventory  of  boats  in  St. 
Paul  and  on  White  Bear  Lake  (for  rental)  in  the  early  1880s  - were  previously  unknown 
and  add  an  interesting  facet  into  the  workings  of  Dingle’s  company. 

In  mid-March  1884,  the  workshop  was  described  as  “a  one  and  a half  story  frame 
building,  owned  and  occupied  by  Jos.  Dingle,  as  a place  where  he  made  boats”.  A 
portion  of  the  Boat  Works  building  and  “some  fine  lumber,  suitable  for  boats,  was 
partially  destroyed”  in  a fire.  The  insured  monetary  loss  was  $250,  with  Dingle’s 
assurances  that  “he  will  go  right  on  with  his  business  of  boat  building  the  same  as 
though  no  fire  had  occurred,  that  all  his  orders  will  be  promptly  filled,  and  all  new 


^Joseph  and  Elizabeth  Dingle  had  15  children,  three  of  whom  died  before  age  3,  three  of  whom  died  aged  21-26,  and  one  who 
died  at  age  36;  outlived  by  both  their  parents  (Ancestry.com). 


23 


business  will  have  prompt  attention”.  The  St.  Paul  Fire  Commissioner’s  report  stated 
that  “children  playing  with  stove”  caused  the  fire.  MHM  suggests  the  damage  was 
minimal  due  to  the  proximity  of  Engine  Company  No.  6 next  door  to  the  Boat  Works. 
The  fire  damage  may  have  prompted  Dingle  to  make  construction  alterations  to  the 
Boat  Works  building  at  a cost  of  $500  by  the  end  of  1884  In  1888,  Dingle  participated  in 
the  3rd  annual  St.  Paul  Winter  Carnival,  where  “a  beautiful  sailing  yacht,  with  canvas 
spread,  bore  the  name  of  J.  Dingle,  the  boat  builder”  in  the  Industrial  Parade.  In  June 
1893,  the  Boat  Works  participated  in  another  parade  that  showcased  St.  Paul 
businesses,  comprised  of  manufacturers,  jobbers,  and  retailers  divisions.  The  3-day 
celebration  centered  on  honoring  J.J.  Hill  to  commemorate  the  completion  of  the 
transcontinental  Great  Northern  Railway  line  to  Washington  (St.  Paul  Daily  Globe 
1884a,c,  1885a,  1888a,  1893b). 


Inside  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  factory.  The  date  applied  to  the  image  is  1920.  However,  it  may 
be  the  interior  of  the  airport  facility  at  a later  date  (MNHS  HE5.4p1 , digitized  by  MHM). 

Joseph  Dingle’s  influence  on  sailboat  design,  construction,  and  racing  on  White  Bear 
Lake  in  the  1880s  to  after  1900  is  evidenced  by  the  number  of  boats  - found  in  the 
historical  record  - built  by  the  firm  during  this  period.  Among  them  are:  Catamaran 
(1884,  owned  by  Dingle),  Manitou  (1889),  Nushka  (1889),  Merry  Monarch  (1891), 
Albatross  (1892),  Galatea  (1892),  Secret  (1892),  Sinbad  (1892),  WhaleA/alkyrie  (1892), 
Columbia  (1893,  owned  by  Dingle),  Nancy  Ruth  (<1 893),  Britannia  (1894),  Katie  D 
(1894),  Banshee  (1895),  Esmeralda  (1895),  Petrel  (1895),  and  Gamma  (1904).  These 
boats  were  primarily  connected  with  members  of  the  White  Bear  Yacht  Club.  On  Lake 
Minnetonka,  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  sailboats  Gusty  Glider  (1889)  and  Elizabeth 
(1890)  were  constructed  for  the  same  costumer.7  The  designs  of  successive  Dingle 
sloops  were  surpassing  each  other  during  White  Bear  regattas.  Regarding  Columbia,  it 
was  reported  “Joseph  Dingle  has  put  a new  sloop  on  the  lake.  It  is  built  on  somewhat 


7See  the  chart  on  pages  36-49  for  specifics  on  the  individual  Dingle  Boats. 


24 


different  lines  from  any  of  the  other  yachts. ..is  riding  at  Ramaley’s  mooring.  She  is  built 
with  a sharply  rising  bow  and  a great  forward  over-hang.  The  builder’s  idea  seems  to  be 
to  have  her  go  over  the  water  rather  than  through  it.”  Sometimes  Joseph  was  part  of 
Columbia’s  crew  under  Captain  Gene  Ramaley.  When  Dingle’s  newly-launched  sloop 
Katie  D beat  his  older  Nushka  and  Columbia  by  over  5 minutes,  “Dingle  kissed  and 
hugged  the  jib  with  joy  when  she  came  in”  (St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1893d,e,  1894e). 

By  later  summer  1895,  Joseph  Dingle  was  characterized  as  one  of  the  “old  and  well- 
known  boat  builders”  in  Twin  Cities  yacht  racing  circles.  In  the  new  century,  the  Boat 
Works  took  contracts  from  the  City  of  St.  Paul’s  Park  Board  and  Board  of  Water 
Commissioners,  and  Ramsey  County,  to  build  boats  and  supply  gear  such  as  oars  and 
oar  locks.  In  July  1900,  the  Boat  Works  furnished  5 cedar-planked  row  boats  with 
oarlocks  to  the  Park  Board  for  $168.75  - $33.75  for  each  boat  through  the  Board  of 
Park  Commissioners  (Warrant  2851).  Another  order,  delivered  in  early  June  1901,  was 
comprised  of  40  Dingle  cedar  planked  rowboats  at  a price  of  $28  per  vessel  ($1,120.00, 
Warrant  2940).  MHM  suggests  the  decreased  price  per  boat  might  reflect  the  lack  of 
metal  oarlocks  in  the  big  order  - or  a bulk  order  discount.  These  45  boats  replaced  30 
‘old’  row  boats,  mostly  built  in  1894,  deemed  “unfit  for  further  service”  at  7 years  of  age. 
Further,  Dingle  submitted  two  estimates  “for  building,  equipping  and  furnishing  an 
electric  launch  [Warrant  2879]  for  Lake  Como”  (City  of  St.  Paul  1902,  432-433,  436, 
898-899,  902;  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895c;  St.  Paul  Globe  1900a-b).  The  firm  delivered 
the  electric  vessel  in  the  summer  1900  for  $1,000,  with  payment  deferred  until  1901. 8 

In  the  early  morning  of  April  27,  1902,  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  was  substantially 
damaged  by  fire.  St.  Paul  Fire  Station  6,  next  door  to  the  boat  factory,  responded 
quickly  - as  the  firefighters  had  done  in  1884.  The  factory  was  described  as  a “three- 
story  building.  The  lower  floor,  known  as  the  boat  repository,  was  well  filled  with 
launches  and  small  row  boats.  These,  with  one  or  two  exceptions,  were  protected  by 
the  salvage  corps.  A launch  belonging  to  F.  B.  Doran  was  among  the  boats  saved. ..The 
entire  loss  is  estimated  at  $3,000  and  is  covered  by  insurance.  The  loss  to  the  building 
is  placed  at  $1,000.  Another  $1,000  will  cover  the  cedar  lumber  destroyed  and  a third 
$1,000  is  the  figure  placed  on  the  damaged  boats.  The  origin  of  the  fire  is  unknown”. 
Frank  B.  Doran  was  the  former  mayor  of  St.  Paul,  and  other  large  launches  were  also 
saved  from  the  fire,  including  Grace  (ordered  by  George  Gillette  of  the  Gillette-Herzog 
Manufacturing  Company  for  Lake  Minnetonka),  Absaraka  (ordered  by  Peter  Lees  of  the 
American  Bridge  Company),  and  a boat  associated  with  the  Norberg  Brewing  Company. 
Remarkably,  the  Moore  Boat  Works  in  Wayzata  experienced  a large  loss  due  to  fire  in 
mid-February  1902,  just  over  2 months  before  the  Dingle  fire9  (McGinnis  2010,  96; 
Minneapolis  Journal  1902d;  Minneapolis  Tribune  1902a;  St.  Paul  Globe  1902). 

MHM  contends  the  Dingle  factory  did  not  recover  quickly  enough  from  the  fire  to  fulfill 
small  boat  construction  orders  for  the  City  of  St.  Paul  in  1902,  but  the  Boat  Works 


8lt  is  noteworthy  that  the  Lake  Como  electric  launch  constructed  by  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  carried  4,289  people  around 
the  lake  during  the  1901  season,  May  1 -October  1,  charging  10  cents  per  person  (Board  of  Park  Commissioners  1902,  25;  St.  Paul 
Globe  1900a). 

9Moore  Boat  Works  lost  80  row  boats,  most  of  them  on  order  for  the  Twin  City  Rapid  Transit  Company,  and  a large  warehouse 
- valued  at  $7,000.  However,  the  company’s  other  buildings  - and  private  houses  - did  not  burn,  and  4 large  launches  were  saved 
from  damage  including  Tanager  and  Widgeon,  and  10  row  boats  and  sailboats  were  saved  (McGinnis  2010,  240,  270;  Minneapolis 
Journal  1902a). 


25 


completed  large  launches  - Grace  (1902)  and  Absaraka  (1902)10  - and  returned  to 
capacity  in  1903.  As  part  of  the  recovery,  the  Boat  Works  began  construction  of  fast 
racing  auto  boats,  several  vessels  that  won  contests  on  Lake  Minnetonka,  in  Duluth, 
and  other  places.  These  watercraft  include  Buster  Boy  (1904),  Bisbee  (1905),  Janes 
Power  Boat  (1905),  Westman  (1905),  White  (1905),  North  Butte  (1906),  Globe 
Consolidated  (1907),  Fritz  (1908),  Dick  Six  (1909),  Dingle-Capitol  (1909),  Jeannette 
(1909),  Pine  Cone  (1909),  Sea  Breeze  (1909),  Finola  (<1 91 0),  Panama  (1915),  Dolly 
Dingle  (1916),  Ace  (1920),  Hortense  (-1920),  and  Northwind  (-1920).  These  fast  boats 
were  long  and  heavy,  upwards  of  40.00+  feet,  with  large  and  powerful  engines.* 11 

One  maritime  historical  link  between  Fred  Dingle  and  Gar  Wood  - famed  boat  racing 
pioneer,  boat  builder  and  designer,  inventor,  and  businessman  - is  linked  to  the 
construction  of  fast  auto  boats.  Wood  grew  up  in  northern  Minnesota,  including  Duluth 
from  ages  10-28.  Gar  became  involved  with  boats  and  boating  and  worked  for  Richard 
Schell,  owner  of  many  Dingle  boats  including  Bisbee,  North  Butte,  Globe  Consolidated, 
Fritz,  Dick  Six,  and  Dingle-Capitol.  In  a 1935  interview,  Wood  described  his  discovery  of 
fast  Dingle  boats  and  his  pursuit  of  a friendship  with  Fred  Dingle  after  Wood  moved  to 
St.  Paul.  In  1905  during  trials  of  Schell’s  Bisbee  on  Lake  Minnetonka,  Dingle,  Wood, 
Schell,  and  pilot  Mattson  of  Globe  Iron  Works  were  pictured  in  the  boat  - a rare  image 
of  3 significant  figures  in  Minnesota  maritime  and  boat-building  history  (Desmond  2004, 
2;  Fishman  1989,  41;  Minneapolis  Journal  1905b). 


ON  BOAED  THE  BISBEE. 

Those  in  the  Boat  Are  Richard  Scholl,  the  Owner; 
Max  Matteion,  Who  Held  the  Wheel;  Wood 
of  Duluth,  Who  Ran  tho  Engine;  Dingle,  Who 
Built  the  Hull. 


Designers  and  Builders 

OF  Ml  KINDS  OF 

Pleasure  Craft 

IJ< 

iseph  Dingle  Boat  Wort 

IS 

ESTABLISHED  I8B0 

421  Clinton  Avenue 

SI.  Paul,  Minn. 

T 

Up-lo-Date  Runabouts  a Specialty 

Left:  Fred  Dingle,  GarWood,  Richard  Schell,  and  Mattson  on  Lake  Minnetonka  in  Bisbee  ( Minneapolis 

Journal  1905b). 

Right:  Brochure,  roughly  1920  (Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works,  MHM  Collection,  digitized  by  MHM). 


10See  the  chart  on  pages  36-49  for  specifics  on  the  individual  Dingle  Boats. 

11  Ibid. 


26 


The  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  continued  to  provide  boats  and  boat  gear  to  the  Park 
Board  in  1903  and  over  the  next  25  years,  including  a row  boat  with  oars  (Order  13681 , 
July  9,  1903,  $33.50);  oar  locks  (Order  3602,  December  1,  1903,  $2.50);  launch 
steering  wheel  (Voucher  15062,  June  1905,  $4.50);  boat  (Voucher  15694,  May  1906, 
$35.00);  50  row  boats  (Order  4208,  June  1906,  $1,400);  50  row  boats  (Order  4526,  May 
1907,  $1,400);  boat  fittings  (Voucher  16931,  November  1907,  $5.25);  oar  locks  (Order 
4777,  July  17,  1907,  $2.40);  50  row  boats  (Order  5169,  June  7,  1909,  $1,400.00);  row 
boats  and  launch  cover  (Voucher  1478,  September  1909,  $86.10);  30  row  boats  (Order 
5548,  June  1910,  $840.00);  and  50  wooden  row  boats  (Order  6045,  July  3,  1911, 
$1,400).  In  1915,  the  Water  Department  Fund  spent  $99.75  and  the  Parks  Department 
spent  $49.50  on  unknown  goods  or  services  from  Dingle,  and  Ramsey  County 
purchased  oars  (Order  365731,  $7.50)  and  a pulley  and  cleat  (Order  366939,  $3.20) 
from  Dingle  in  1928  (Board  of  Park  Commissioners  1905,  66,  1907,  61,  1908,  65,  1909, 
44,  1910,  1911,  78-79,  1912,  14,  37,  43;  Board  of  Water  Commissioners  1906,  39, 
1907,  39,  1908,  49  1910,  48;  City  Comptroller  1904,  250;  City  of  St.  Paul  1915,  967, 
1027;  Ramsey  County  1928,  41,  92). 


w«  c*rry  in  8tocv  a f*1"  r: 

row  Boats.  Hunting  Boats.  Oars  and  Boat 
Supplies 

Our  Family  Ro*  BoU  is  conceded  to 

be  one  o,  the  safe*  and  easiest  rowmg 
boats  built. 

buying  a "Oingl."  B“l  our 
Comers  have  the  benefit  of  years  e»- 
perience. 

Before  purchasing  a Motor  Boat  or 
Row  Boat,  give  us  a chance  to  figure  with 

you. 


ROW  BOATS,  HUNTING  BOATS  AND  CANOES 


Get  Our 


prices  and  Specifications 


Estimates  gladly  furnished  on  all  kinds 

of  boat  work. 


Brochure  pages 
(Joseph  Dingle  Boat 
Works,  MHM 
Collection,  digitized 
by  MHM). 

Dingle  Advertisement 
(St.  Paul  Daily  Globe 
1888b). 


AI1  Kinds  of  p'  ~ 

**»*i<ll  Av  , 

***Mr»ii  . 


154  FOOT  BOAT,  $25! 


JOSEPH  DIN6LE,  - BOAT  BUILDER, 

Ccr.  Isabel  and  Clinton.  West  St.  Paul, 
One  block  from  street  cars. 


f ,.,  . ‘ 

" ;to  f 

n°r>- 

f. 

nnh«‘  „r  . 

W*h«*Po»" 

hstaJi 

wh^^Z^^fmotor 

Pr‘ce8  0f  d 

fo  matery  , ^ ^ >n  Pri„ 
fin/sb.  a s used  i „ *•  accord. 

consfruciion  ^ 


27 


A group  of  Dingle  boats  constructed  for  the  US  Army  Corps  of  Engineers  (USACE)  for 
the  Rock  Island,  IL  District  - later  the  St.  Paul  District  - are  35-foot  long  screw  launches 
and  are  found  in  government  records.  These  vessels  include  Hiawatha  (1912), 
Minnehaha  (1912),  Quincy  (1912),  Chippewa  (1913),  Galena  (1913),  Minneiska  (1913), 
Trimbelle  (1913),  and  Zumbro  (1913).  The  Nodin  (1915),  Chippewa  (1935),  and  St. 
Croix  (1935)  were  slightly  smaller  than  the  earlier  launches.  These  launches  were 
designed  to  carry  soft  Kenyon  tops,  often  made  of  leather,  on  metal  frames  that  could 
be  raised  or  lowered;  the  modern  equivalent  is  a bimini  top.  Moving  on  from  the  early 
auto  boats,  Dingle  constructed  triple  cockpit  runabout  Gerry  Lo  in  1929  for  Frank  W. 
Griswold,  founder  of  the  Griswold  Safety  Signal  Company  for  the  astounding  amount  of 
$25,000.  Griswold  and  his  company  were  known  for  designing  and  developing  railroad 
crossing  signals  and  traffic  signs.  Griswold  acquired  several  patents  for  his  inventions 
starting  with  the  “Bobby”  signal,  in  addition  to  a rotating  stop  sign  designed  for  either  the 
middle  of  the  road  or  roadside  at  railroad  crossings.  Gerry  Lo  was  launched  at  Lake 
Minnetonka  in  1929  and  in  the  same  boathouse  until  1992,  when  she  was  sold  after 
Griswold’s  death.  Labeled  “the  most  famous  runabout  ever  built  in  the  state  of 
Minnesota”,  she  was  sold  at  auction  in  October  2010  for  $285,000  (Mecum  Auctions 
2010a,  64-67,  2010b,  4-5;  Railway  Signaling  and  Communications  1927,  121-122).12 


UFI-yjJJJ  u-Bool* 

Built  In  D,N  , o(  ro(ntM.  I 

for  *h  line* 

in*.  Roomy.  . 

l 

material*.  i 

llnUh  And  don*  I 
mu*«>r*nce  chc»Pcr 


[0  sx.vo)^M^- 


J&*  (Bioat 

c.st.i8B0 


A Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  advertisement 
showcasing  a runabout. 


In  mid-February  1931,  St.  Paul’s  Department  of  Public  Works  granted  “Joseph  Dingle 
Boat  Works  permission  to  use  a portion  of  the  levee  which  lies  between  the  easterly  line 
of  Dunwell  & Spencer’s  Addition  and  the  westerly  line  of  2nd  Addition  of  Brooklynd 
Addition  and  the  northerly  right-of-way  of  the  R.  I.  Ry.  Co.”.  Dingle  required  the  levee 
use  because  of  the  Boat  Works  expansion  in  1934  when  Dingle  constructed  a new  one- 
story  40  by  50-foot  factory  at  596  Texas  Street.  Regardless  of  the  street  address,  this 
new  building  was  known  as  ‘Dingle  Boat  Works,  Mississippi  River  at  Airport’;  it  was 
located  at  the  northeast  corner  of  the  St.  Paul  Downtown  Airport  Holman  Field 
(Commissioner  of  Public  Works  1931,  38;  Minnesota  Resources  Commission  1941, 
117;  Steel  1934,  201).  The  Boat  Works  business  office  remained  on  Isabel  Street.  While 
Dingle  was  known  to  design  and  build  larger  vessels  with  substantial  superstructures 
prior  to  the  construction  of  the  new  facility  - including  the  55.00-foot  long  Albert  Lea 
(1908),  33.00-foot  long  Roamer,  42.00-foot  long  Calista  (1920-1925),  and  particularly 


12See  the  chart  on  pages  36-49  for  specifics  on  the  individual  Dingle  Boats. 


28 


the  120.00-foot  North  Star  (1922)13  - the  proximity  of  the  Texas  Street  factory  to  the 
river,  and  the  addition  of  marine  railways,  allowed  efficient  launching  of  larger  boats. 
Further,  docks  supplied  ‘on-the-water  storage’  where  the  boats  could  be  fitted  out  while 
floating,  freeing-up  factory  space  to  be  used  for  more  boatbuilding. 


Above:  A 1916  plat  map  of  St. 

Paul  south  of  the  river.  The 
regular  planned  streets  have 
never  followed  this  plan.  The 
location  of  Dingle’s  factory  at 
596  Texas  Street  is  marked  in 
red  (Hopkins  1916,  13). 


Right:  This  1937  aerial  image 
records  the  Dingle  Boat  Works, 
circled  in  red  (John  R.  Borchert 
Map  Library,  1937,  27  October). 


Exploiting  the  new,  larger  facility,  in  the  1930s  the  Boat  Works  took  orders  for  larger 
houseboats  and  cabin  cruisers,  boats  not  meant  for  racing  or  maximized  speed.  These 
craft  include  EllenRuth  (1933),  a Houseboat  (1933),  Mayo  Family  Cruiser  (1935), 
Glengarry  (1936),  and  the  Cushner  Houseboat  (1937).  During  World  War  II,  the  Joseph 
Dingle  Boat  Works  constructed  the  SC-497  Class  Submarine  Chasers  SC-1000,  SC- 


13Dr.  Will  Mayo  commissioned  Dingle  to  construct  the  large  motor  yacht  North  Star,  she  took  15  men  working  8 months  to 
complete,  and  a purpose-built  building  was  constructed  in  St.  Paul  to  accommodate  the  build.  See  the  chart  on  pages  36-49  for 
specifics  on  the  individual  Dingle  Boats. 


29 


1001,  and  SC-100214  using  specifications  supplied  by  the  US  Navy.  The  subchaser- 
building program  was  designed  to  produce  438  wooden  boats  from  45  smaller  boat- 
building firms  around  the  nation,  leaving  steel  for  warship  fabrication  and  warship 
construction  to  very  large  shipyards.  The  launchings  of  SC-1000  and  SC-1002  into  the 
Mississippi  River  in  late  October  1942  and  early  April  1943  were  noteworthy.  “The  first 
combat  vessel  of  the  war  to  be  built  in  the  Twin  City  area  was  launched  at  the  Dingle 
boat  works  here  today...  12-year  old  Patricia  Ann  Towle  smashed  a bottle  of  soda  water 
against  the  bow”  and  “the  third  sub  chaser  built  in  St.  Paul  goes  down  the  ways  at  the 
Dingle  boat  works  today  when  Delores  Becker,  daughter  of  Michael  Becker,  foreman  at 
the  plant,  christens  the  ship.  The  Diesel-powered  110-foot  S.  C.  1001  is  a sister  ship  to 
sub  chasers  launched  in  October  and  November.  It  is  equipped  with  depth  charges”. 
Lastly,  Dingle  constructed  the  towboat  Cartasca  [Cargill  and  Itasca]  for  Cargill, 
launching  the  vessel  in  September  1944.  Cargill  family  members  John  Cargill,  Jr., 
Cargill  MacMillan,  and  Austen  Cargill  cruised  down  the  Mississippi  River  in  November, 
after  Cartasca’s  complete  out-fitting.  Cartasca  moved  barges  of  grain  from  Port  Cargill 
in  Savage  on  the  Minnesota  River  to  points  on  the  Mississippi  River.  In  December  1945 
the  towboat  sank  during  the  process  of  getting  her  prepared  for  winter  storage,  and  was 
raised  during  warmer  weather  ( Brainerd  Daily  Dispatch  1945;  Broehl  1992,  670; 
Evening  Tribune  1942;  Moorhead  Daily  News  1942,  1943;  Republican  Herald  1951; 
Sables  2005).15 


This  1945  aerial  image  records  the  Dingle  Boat  Works,  in  the  red  square,  just  prior  to  its  sale  to  the 
Midway  Lumber  Company.  Marine  railways  and  docks  are  clearly  seen,  with  vessels  moored  (John  R. 

Borchert  Map  Library,  1945). 


14See  the  chart  on  pages  36-49  for  specifics  on  the  individual  Dingle  Boats. 
15lbid. 


30 


By  1946,  George  Towle  (probably  Patricia  Ann’s  father)  either  owned  the  Joseph  Dingle 
Boat  Works  or  was  the  manager  of  the  firm.  Later  that  year,  in  early  May  1946,  the 
Minneapolis  Dredging  Company  purchased  Dingle’s  airport  facilities  and  subsequently 
leased  the  property  to  the  Twin  City  Barge  and  Towing  Company.  However,  the  Dingle 
Boat  Works  (not  the  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works)  existed  as  a subsidiary  of  the  Midway 
Lumber  Company  at  630  North  Prior  Avenue  in  St.  Paul  until  1949  ( Marine  News  1946, 
113;  Minnesota  Resources  Commission  1946,  316;  Research  Division  1949,  185;  The 
Rudder  1947,  46;  Waterways  Journal  1996,  42). 

Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat 

MHM  documented  the  DOMB  on  February  17  and  March  1,  8,  and  10,  2017  at  the 
MNHS  warehouse.  The  DOMB’s  wooden  hull  is  16.00  feet  long,  4.00  feet  in  the  beam, 
with  a 15.00-inch  depth  of  hold.  The  stem  consists  of  a triangular  outer  stempost  that  is 
curved  and  attached  to  the  keel.  Large  bolts  driven  through  the  outer  stempost  attach  it 
to  the  inner  stempost  (not  seen).  The  bolts  go  through  a bronze  keel  strip  that  is 
attached  to  the  stempost,  keel,  and  lower  transom  at  the  stern,  where  it  is  attached  with 
slot  head  screws.  A Maxwell  anchor  roller  with  an  anchor  lock  was  attached  to  the  bow 
but  is  now  loose,  although  it  is  accompanying  the  craft.  It  is  not  original  to  the  boat  since 
it  was  manufactured  in  1953  (Maxwell  1953).  A black  mushroom  anchor  accompanies 
the  boat.  A round  hole  bored  through  the  stempost  serves  as  a tow  ring  and  mooring 
attachment.  At  the  stern,  the  keel  protrudes  from  the  hull  bottom  and  is  rectangular  in 
cross-section.  The  gunwale  has  no  caprail  and  a foredeck  covers  the  gunwale  at  the 
bow.  The  aft  edge  of  the  foredeck  is  shaped  by  coaming  that  extends  about  12  inches 
along  each  side  of  the  boat  and  is  attached  to  the  inside  of  the  gunwale.  Futtocks  are 
visible  between  the  narrow  beams  that  comprise  the  gunwale  along  the  aft  3/4  of  the 
vessel;  the  outer  beam  acts  as  a rubrail. 

The  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (MHM) 


31 


Maxwell 
Anchor  Roller 
and 

Mushroom 

Anchor 


Above:  The  bow  and 
foredeck  of  the  Dingle 
boat,  looking  aft. 


Right:  The  forward 
bench  and  foredeck  of 
the  Dingle  boat,  looing 
forward.  Note  the 
longitudinal  stringers  and 
keelson. 


The  hull  is  clinker-built  (lapstrake),  has  a wide  flat  bottom,  and  the  aft  section  of  the  boat 
has  minor  tumblehome  where  the  hull  narrows  from  the  waterline  to  the  gunwale.  The 
transom  rakes  slightly  aft  and  is  comprised  of  2 wide  planks;  the  gunwale  edge  of  the 
top  plank  rounded  port  and  starboard,  and  flat  amidships  - designed  to  take  an 
outboard  motor.  The  transom  plate  is  actually  6 vertical  planks  that  enhances  the 
transom’s  strength  when  the  motor  is  on  the  boat,  attached  to  the  inner  transom  face. 


32 


Inside  the  hull  at  the  transom,  a centerline  knee  is  attached  to  the  boat’s  bottom  and 
adds  strength  to  the  stern.  Two  horizontal  knees  on  the  port  and  starboard  quarters 
inside  the  gunwale  also  add  stability  and  strength.  The  DOMB  has  thin  frames  attached 
to  the  inner  hull,  providing  rigidity  to  the  vessel.  As  best  as  MHM  can  discern,  each 
frame  is  one  long  thin  piece  of  wood  that  has  been  curved  into  a wide  U shape.  A wide 
keelson  rests  on  top  of  the  keel  and  8 stringers  are  attached  to  the  top  of  the  floors,  4 
on  port  and  4 on  starboard.  The  2 stringers  furthest  to  port  and  starboard  are  shorter 
than  the  other  6,  stopping  forward  of  amidships. 


Above:  Transom 
stern 


Above:  The  composite 
transom  plate  and 
gunwale  level  stern  knees 


Left:  Longitudinal  stringers 
and  keelson  with  a foot 
brace  chock  and  foot  rest 


Longitudinal  stringers  are  attached  to  the  futtocks  on  both  sides  extending  from  the 
stern  quarters  to  the  bow.  Benches  rest  on  the  longitudinal  stringers  from  amidships  to 
the  stern  along  the  vessel’s  sides,  widening  across  the  boat  at  the  stern  to  provide  a 
wide  bench  for  the  boat’s  operator.  The  stern  bench  is  comprised  of  several  wooden 
pieces  supported  by  2 athwartships  riders  sitting  on  top  of  floors;  the  forward  rider  is 
actually  a bulwark  that  creates  an  enclosed  stern  area.  A removable  seat  back 


33 


comprised  of  2 wooden  slats  attached  to  vertical  posts  slots  into  rectangular  cuts  in  the 
decking  and  leans  against  an  athwartships  beam  attached  to  the  gunwale  on  port  and 
starboard.  Behind  the  seat  back,  removable  decking  - comprised  of  wood  sections  - 
allows  access  to  the  fuel  tank  that  is  no  longer  extant.  A gap  between  two  of  the 
removable  deck  sections  exists  to  allow  a fuel  line  to  run  from  the  outboard  motor  to  the 
fuel  tank,  as  well  as  access  to  the  steering  cables. 


An  athwartships  amidships  bench  is  attached  to  the  forward  edge  of  the  side  benches 
that  are  attached  to  the  vessels  sides  with  metal  braces.  Another  bench  is  located 
forward,  resting  on  the  longitudinal  stringers  like  the  other  athwartships  and  side 
benches.  Four  metal  oarlocks,  2 on  each  side,  are  attached  to  the  gunwale  amidships 
aft  of  the  athwartships  benches,  indicating  where  rowers  should  sit.  Two  mismatched 
oars,  one  with  copper  applied  to  the  tip  of  the  blade,  a wooden  boat  hook  with  a metal 
end,  and  a carved  wooden  flag  mast  are  associated  with  the  watercraft.16  Additionally, 
two  wooden  chocks  attached  to  the  boat’s  keelson  serve  as  the  rower’s  foot  braces. 
Forward  of  each  chock,  removable  flat  platforms  serve  as  foot  rests  for  the  rowers  feet; 
an  additional  forward  foot  rest  is  located  under  the  foredeck  for  a front  bench 
passenger’s  feet.  The  watercraft  is  held  together  with  slot  head  screws  and  short  nails, 


16MHM  suggests  one  of  the  oars  and  the  mast  were  not  donated  to  the  MNHS  with  the  Dingle  boat  but  are  now  erroneously 
associated  with  it. 


34 


the  hull  is  painted  white,  and  the  foredeck  and  coaming  are  unpainted.  The  unpainted 
top  strake  on  both  port  and  starboard  has  the  outlines  of  the  numbers  and  letters  that 
comprise  the  boat’s  registration  number  - WS  5736  EG. 


The  vital  statistics  linked  to  Wisconsin  registration  number  5736  EG  indicates  it  was  last 
licensed  by  Lucille  Moeller  in  1989  and  the  wooden  boat  is  16.00  feet  long  (Wisconsin 
DNR,  personal  communication,  March  6,  2017).  The  history  attached  to  the  DOMB 
indicates  that  Fred  Dingle  gifted  the  boat  to  his  good  friend  Bud  Moeller  in  the  early 
1930s.  Moeller  left  instructions  with  his  wife  Lucille  to  pass  the  DOMB  to  Captain 
William  D.  Bowell  after  his  death.  Therefore,  the  DOMB  became  the  property  of  Bowell 
sometime  around  1989  and  he  donated  the  boat  to  the  MNHS  in  2004.  The  ‘Jos.  Dingle 
Boat  Works’  name  plate  was  removed  from  the  DOMB  by  Bowell;  he  stored  it  in  a 
tobacco  can  marked  with  the  initials  “F.D.”.  The  can  was  a Christmas  gift  to  Fred  from 
Bud  in  1927  (Bowell  2004).  Captain  Bowell  was  the  founder  of  St.  Paul’s  Padelford 
Riverboat  Company.  The  DOMB  is  stable  and  in  fantastic  condition.  MHM  suggests  the 
boat  remain  on  its  keel,  the  bottom  supported  in  its  entirety  to  prevent  hogging  and 
sagging. 


35 


MHM’s  3D  scans  of  the  Joseph  Dingle 
Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat.  The 
scanning  process  included  several  scans 
saved  as  separate  files.  Because  of  the 
vagaries  in  lighting,  the  color  version  of 
the  scanned  images  appears  like  a 
patchwork  (right  and  below). 


f 


36 


A List  of  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  Vessels 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

Joseph  Dingle 
Boat  Works 
Outboard 
Motor  Boat 

Outboard 

Motor 

Launch 

Wood 

1910s- 

Early 

1930s 

16.00’ 

4.00’ 

15.00” 

Outboard 

Motor/Oars 

Absaraka 

Launch 

Wood 

1902 

Gasoline 

Ace™ 

Limousine 

Runabout 

Wood 

1920 

33.00’ 

5.50’ 

Thoroughbred 

4 Cycle  Type 

B Engine,  32- 
40  HP,  Red 
Wing  Boat 
Company 

Ace 

Motor  Boating  1922,  18 


Albatross iy 

Catboat 

Wood 

1892 

Sail 

Albert  Lea 20 

Raised  Deck 
Cruiser 

Wood 

1908 

55.00’  11.50’ 

Twin  Screw 
Engines,  60 
HP 

Albert  Lea 
Cole  1910,  378 


Banshee 


1st  Class 
Sloop 


Cedar 


1895 

29.00’ 

Sail 


Bickford  Boat^  Catboat 


Wood 


1914  16.00’ 


Sail 


17 Minneapolis  Journal  1902d. 

18 Motor  Boating  1922,18;  Pacific  Motor  Boat  1920,  36. 

19Sf.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1892b,g,  1892i,  1893g,  1894d. 

20Evening  Tribune.  11.16.1908;  Cole  1910,  378,  380;  Daily  Gate  City  1908;  Motor  Boat  1908,  58. 
21  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895a-b. 

22 Daily  Missoulian  1914. 


37 


Name 


Type 


Material 


Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 


Bisbee 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 


Wood 


Bisbee 

Minneapolis  Journal  1905b 


1905  27.00’ 


i;  s:  •; 


4 Cylinder 
White 
Gasoline 
Engine,  20 
HP,  Globe 
Iron  Works, 
Minneapolis 


Britannia 


Sailboat 


Wood 


-1894 


Sail 


Buster  Boy25 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 


Wood 


1904 


Gasoline 
Engine,  20 
HP,  Globe 
Iron  Works, 


Calista 26 

Launch 

Oak 

1920- 

1925 

42.00’ 

10.67’ 

Grey  Marine 
Engine,  85 

HP 

Cartasca 27 

Towboat 

Wood 

1944 

40.00’ 

33.00’ 

6.50’ 

8 Chrysler 
Marine 
Engines, 
1160  HP 

Cartasca 

Republican  Herald  1951 


Catamaran 


Sailboat 


Wood 


<1884 


Sail 


Chippewa 29 

USACE 

Screw 

Launch 

Wood 

1913 

35.00’ 

5.67’ 

3.33’ 

4 Cylinder 
Capitol 
Engine,  40 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Chippewa dU 

USACE 

Wood  d 

1935 

34.00’ 

Motor 

23McGinnis  2010,  21;  Minneapolis  Journal  1905a-b;  Minneapolis  Tribune  1905;  Minnetonka  Record  1905;  Motor  Age  1905,  19; 
Power  Boat  News  1 905b,  1 06. 

24 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1894f. 

25 Power  Boat  News  1 905b;  Minneapolis  Journal  1 905b. 

26Barron  County  Historical  Society  ND. 

27Broehl  1992,  670. 

28 St. Paul  Daily  Globe  1 884b. 

29USACE  1913,  3638,  1914,  4324-4326,  1917,  3928-3929. 

30  Waterways  Journal  1975,  8. 


38 


Name  Type  Material  Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 


City  of  St.  Paul 
Rowboats' 


31 


309+ 

Rowboats 

Wood 

-1894- 
1911  + 

Oars 


Row  Boats  on  Lake  Como 
MNHS-MR2.9SP4.1Clp7 
Digitized  by  MHM 


Columbia 

Sloop 

Wood 

1893 

30.00’ 

Sail 

Columbia 

St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895b 


COLUMBIA. 


Como  Park 
Launch33 

Launch 

Wood 

1900 

Electric  Motor 

Cushner 

Houseboat34 

Houseboat 

Wood 

1937 

50.00 

Gasoline 

Cushner  Houseboat 
Divine  2008 


31  See  earlier  section. 

32 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1893d-h,  1894b,  1895a-b. 
33Warrant  2879,  1902. 

34Divine  2008. 


39 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 

Dick  Six 35 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

1909 

39.50’ 

5.33’ 

6 Cylinder 
Capitol 
Engine,  100 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Dingle-Capitol 36 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 


Wood 


1909 


29.00’ 


5.00’ 


6 Cylinder  4 
Cycle  Capitol 
Engine,  1,100 
RPM,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 


Dingle-Capitol 
Power  Boating  1910a,  53 


Dolly  DingleJ ' 

Motor  Boat 

Wood 

1916 

20.00 

Gasoline 

Elizabeth™ 

Catboat 

Wood 

1890 

20.25’ 

8.75’ 

Sail 

Twin  6 

Ellen  Ruth 39 

Launch 

Cypress  & Oak 

1933 

42.00’ 

10.00’ 

Cylinder 

Studebaker 

Engines 

EllenRuth 
City  of  Wahkon 


Ellen  Ruth 

Mille  Lacs  Messenger  2013. 


35 Motor  Boat  1 909a,  64. 

36Cole  1910,  380;  Motor  Boat  1909b,  37,  1909c,  41;  Power  Boating  1910a,  54,  1910b,  350. 

37 Open  Exhaust  1916,  10. 

38McGinnis  2010,  63;  Northwestern  Tourist  1890;  Minneapolis  Times  1896;  Mott  1894,  453. 

39Jenkinson  and  Roberts  1985;  Mille  Lacs  Messenger  1 933a-c,  1938;  Paul  Petty,  personal  communication,  March  13,  2017. 


40 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

Esmeralda 4U 

Catboat 

Wood 

1895 

Sail 

Finola 41 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

<1910 

4 Cylinder 
Capitol 
Engine,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Finola 

Cole  1910,  380. 


* ■ 


Fritz 42 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat/ 
Runabout 

Wood 

<1908 

Motor 

Fritz 

Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  -1920. 
Brochure 
MHM  Collection 
Digitized  by  MHM 


Galatea 


Catboat 


Wood 


1892 


Sail 


Galena 


USACE 

Screw 

Launch 


Wood 


1913 


35.00’ 


5.67’ 


3.33’ 


4 Cycle 
Reverse  Gear 
Engine,  40 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 


Game  Warden 
Boat  I45 


Power  Boat 


Wood 


1928 


26.00’ 


5.83’ 


Engines  with 
Autopulse 
Gasoline 
Supply 
System 


40 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895a,  1895d-e. 

41  Cole  1910,  378,  380. 

42Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  ND;  Fishman  1989,  41. 

43 St.  Paul  Daily  1892b,d,  1893f-g. 

44Rock  Island  Argus  1914.9.25;  USACE  1914,  4345-4347,  1917,  3928-3929. 
44  Waterways  Journal  1975,  8. 

45Dillon  1928,  130. 


41 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

Game  Warden 
Boat  246 

Power  Boat 

Wood 

1928 

26.00’ 

5.83’ 

Engines  with 
Autopulse 
Gasoline 
Supply 
System 

Gamma*' 

Sloop 

Wood 

1904 

Sail 

Gerry  Lo 48 

Triple  Cockpit 
Runabout 

Mahogany 

1929 

30.00’ 

7.08’ 

Curtiss  D-12 
WWI  Aircraft 
Engine 

Gerry  Lo 

Mecum  Auctions  2010,  64,  67. 


Glengarry 49 

Twin  V-Drive 
Chrysler 

Houseboat 

Cypress  & Oak 

1938 

48.83’ 

15.00’ 

4.80’ 

Crown 
Engines,  92 
HP 

Glengarry 

KSTP.com 


Globe 

Consolidated 50 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

1907 

39.92’ 

5.00’ 

6 Cylinder,  4 
Cycle  Doman 
Marine 
Engine,  60 
HP 


46Dillon  1928,  130. 

47 Minneapolis  Journal  1904b;  St.  Paul  Globe  1904a-b. 

48Mecum  Auctions  2010a,  64-67;  Schley  2001,  18-23. 

49Marjanian  ND;  Woodyboater  2013. 

50 Boating  1907b,  54;  Fore  ‘N’  Aft  1907a,  52;  1907b,  27;  Motor  Boat  1907b,  8. 


42 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

Grace 51 

Launch 

Wood 

1902 

Motor 

Gusty  Glided 

Yacht 

Wood 

1889 

20.50’ 

9.00’ 

Sail 

Hiawatha 53 

USACE 

Screw 

Launch 

Cypress 

1912 

35.17’ 

6.21’ 

3.50’ 

4 Cylinder 
Engine,  35 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Hortense 54 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat/ 
Runabout 

Wood 

<1920 

Motor 

Hortense 

Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  -1920. 
Brochure 
MHM  Collection 
Digitized  by  MHM 


Twin  Sterling 

Houseboat55 

Cruising 

Houseboat 

Wood 

1933 

125.00’ 

25.00’ 

Petrel 
Reduction 
Engines,  360 

HP 

Houseboat 
Motor  Boating  1 933 
Back  Cover 


Hydroplane56 

Outboard 

Wood 

1916 

18.00’ 

5-10  HP 
Outboard 
Motor 

Hydroplane 

Open  Exhaust  1917b,  22 


51  McGinnis  2010,  96;  Minneapolis  Journal  1902b-c;  Minneapolis  Tribune  1902b. 

“McGinnis  2010  97;  Minneapolis  Tribune  1889;  Northwestern  Tourist  1889. 

53 Rock  Island  Argus  1912;  USACE  1913,  4234-4235,  1917,  3928-3929. 

54 Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works,  ND. 

55 Motor  Boating  1933,  Back  Cover.  This  boat  may  not  have  been  constructed  since  Dingle  listed  2 Sterling  engines  for  sale  - 
cheap  - in  the  February  1934  issue  of  Motor  Boating  on  page  301. 
x Open  Exhaust  1917b,  22. 


43 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 

Janes  Power 
Boat57 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat/ 
Runabout 

Wood 

1905 

Motor 

Jeannette 58 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat/ 
Runabout 

Mahogany 

1909 

42.00 

5.83’ 

6 Cylinder 
Capitol 
Engine,  100 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Jeannette 

Cole  1910,  380 


Johnson 

Launch59 

Launch 

Wood 

<1916 

28.00’ 

Motor 

Katie  DbU 

Sloop 

Wood 

1894 

Sail 

Katie  D 

St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1 894e 


THE  KATIE  D. 


Lapstrake 

Runabout61 

Outboard 
Motor  Boat 

Wood 

1920s- 

1930s 

16.00’ 

Modern 

Outboard 

Lapstrake  Runabout 
Antique  Boat  America 


57 Power  Boat  News  1905b,  106. 

58Cole  1910,  380-381;  McGinnis  2010,  126;  Minneapolis  Tribune  1909. 

Will  mar  Tribune  1916. 

60 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1894c-e. 

61  Antique  Boat  America  Web  Site. 


44 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 

Manitou™  Catboat  Wood  ] 1889  25.00’  9.50’ 

Sail 

Manitou 

St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1 894a 

if  V\ 

/ ✓/  \ > 

/ to 

/.  x 

| | 

\ 

MANITOU. 

i 

\ 

fj 

- ’Zm 

Mayo  Family 
Boat63 

Cabin  Cruiser 

Wood 

1935 

36.00’ 

Red  Wing 
Arrowhead  4 
Cycle  Engine, 
25-45  HP, 
Red  Wing 

Merry 
Monarch 64 

Catboat 

Wood 

1891 

Sail 

Minnehaha 65 

USACE 

Screw 

Launch 

Cypress 

1912 

35.17’ 

6.21’ 

3.50’ 

4 Cycle 
Capitol 

Engine,  36.50 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Minneiska 66 

USACE 

Screw 

Launch 

Cypress 

1913 

35.17’ 

6.21’ 

3.50’ 

4 Cycle 
Capitol 
Engine,  35 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

Minnewaukan 67 

Launch 

Wood 

1908 

4 Cylinder 
Engine 

Nancy  Ruth™  Catboat  Wood  <1893  Sail 

Nirvana by  Sloop  Wood  1895  23.00  Sail 

62 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1890b-c,  1892c,  1893g. 

63 Motor  Boating  1935,  93. 

64  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1891a-c,  1892c. 

65USACE  1913,  4248-4250,  1914,  4375-4377,  1917,  3928-3929. 
66USACE  1914,  4375-4377,  1917,  3928-3929. 

67 Devils  Lake  Inter-Ocean  <&  Devils  Lake  Free  Press,  1908. 

68 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1893c,g. 


45 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 

Nodin 70 


USACE 

Screw 

Launch 


Cedar 


1915 


30.25 


5.67’ 


2.83’ 


4 Cylinder  4 
Cycle  L Head 
Capitol 
Engine,  20 
HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 


North  Butte 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 


Wood 


1906 


38.00’ 


5.00’ 


6 Cylinder,  4 
Cycle  Doman 
Marine 
Engine,  30 
HP 


North  Butte 
Boating  1907a,  Cover 


Twin  8 

North  Star 72 

Motor  Yacht/ 
Houseboat 

Mahogany 

1922 

120.00’ 

23.00’ 

Cylinder 

Sterling 

Engines,  400 

HP 

North  Star 
MNHS  GV3.61r68 
Digitized  by  MHM 


69 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895e. 

70USACE  1915,  4576-4578. 

71  Boating  1907a,  Cover,  55;  1907b,  54;  Fore  ‘N’  Aft  1907a,  52;  1907b,  27;  Motor  Boat  1907a,  61,  1907b,  8. 

72 Bismarck  Tribune  1922;  Clark  1922,  25;  Bureau  of  Navigation  1923,  248,  1936  921,  1070;  Neuzil  2004,  14-15. 


46 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built  Length  Beam  Depth  Propulsion 

North  Wind73 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

-1920 

Motor 

North  Wind 

Courtesy  of  Steve  Hack 


Nushka 74 

Catboat/ 

Sloop 

Wood 

<1889 

Sail 

Nushka 

St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1 892d 
MNHS  GV3.61Sp125 
Digitized  by  MHM 


Panama 75 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

1915 

Gasoline 

Panama 

Power  Boating  1916,  11 


Peterson 


Outboard  Boat76  Motor  Boat 


Outboard 


Wood 


1914  16.00 


Evinrude 

Outboard 

Motor 


73Steve  Hack,  personal  communication,  March  29,  2017. 

74 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1889,  1890b-c,  1893g. 

75 Open  Ex/?ausM  91 5a,  5-10,  1915b,  10,  1915c,  12,  1917a,  6,  1917b,  12;  Power  Boating  1916,  11. 
76 Daily  Missoulian  1914. 


47 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

Petrel " 

Catboat 

Wood 

1895 

Sail 

Pine  Cone 78 

Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 

Wood 

1909 

32.0073 

5.00’ 

30  HP  Engine 

Roamer 79 


Roamer 
Miron  2007 


Sailboat80  4 Oars  Wood  <1890  1 I I T Oars/Sail 


Salmon  Lake 
Club  Rowboat 

Rowboat 

Wood 

1914 

14.00 

Rowboat 

i81 

Salmon  Lake 
Club  Rowboat 

Rowboat 

Wood 

1914 

16.00 

Rowboat 

282 

SC- 100083 

Twin  8-268A 
Engines, 

Subchaser 

Wood 

1942 

148.00’ 

17.00’ 

6.50’ 

1760  HP, 
General 
Motors 

SC-100184 

Twin  8-268A 
Engines, 

Subchaser 

Wood 

1942 

148.00’ 

17.00’ 

6.50’ 

1760  HP, 
General 
Motors 

77 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1895a-b. 

78Cole  1910,  381 ; Bemidji  Daily  Pioneer  1 909. 

79*ln  1934  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  was  employed  to  install  a new  Universal  45  HP  engine,  replacing  the  original  power 
plant.  Dingle  also  replaced  the  original  soft  Kenyon  Auto  Top  with  another  example  with  increased  waterproofing.  In  turn,  the  1934 
top  was  replaced  by  the  current  enclosed  cabin  in  2002  (Miron  2007). 

80The  ad  offering  this  boat  for  sale  listed  it  as  a “a  four-oared  Dingle  rowboat,  with  sail,  to  exchange  for  a light  pony  cart  or 
buggy  in  god  condition.  For  particulars  address  No.  5,  Fort  Snelling”  (St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1890a). 

81  Daily  Missoulian  1914. 

82 Daily  Missoulian  1914. 

83Naval  History  Division  1976,  735;  NavSource  Online. 

84Naval  History  Division  1976,  735;  NavSource  Online. 


48 


85Naval  History  Division  1976,  735;  NavSource  Online. 

86Schletz  Receipt  from  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works,  March  10,  1939,  www.flicker.com. 

87Cole  1910,  377;  The  Rudder  1909,  151. 

88 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1892a,e. 

89 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1892e,  1893a. 

90  Waterways  Journal  1975,  8. 

91  Stewart  River  Boatworks  Facebook  page.  The  Boatworks  was  restoring  the  boat  at  the  request  of  the  State  of  Minnesota  for 
Tettagouche  State  Park. 


49 


Name 

Type 

Material 

Built 

Length 

Beam 

Depth 

Propulsion 

USACE 

Trimbelle92  Screw  Wood  1913  35.00’ 

Launch 


Westman 
Engine,  25 
HP, 

Enterprise 

Machine 

Company, 

Minneapolis 


Whale/ 
Valkyrie 94 

Sloop 

Wood 

1892 

Sail 

6 Cylinder 
White  Engine, 
80  HP,  Globe 
Iron  Works, 
Minneapolis 


White 

Ellis  1906,  31 


YMCA 

Centerboard 

Boat96 

Row/Sail/ 

Motor 

Wood 

1916 

6 Oars/Sail/ 
Outboard 
Motor 

Zumbro 97 

USACE 

Screw 

Launch 

Wood 

1913 

35.00’ 

5.67’ 

3.33’ 

4 Cycle 
Capitol 
Engine,  40 

HP,  Auto 
Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 

White 


Power/Motor/ 
Auto  Boat 


Wood 


1905  41.00’+ 


6.00’ 


Westman 


Power/Auto 

Boat 


Wood 


1905 


30.0073 

6.00’ 


5.00 


5.67’  3.33’ 


4 Cycle 
Reverse 
Gear,  40  HP, 
Auto  Engine 
Works,  St. 
Paul 


92USACE  1913,  3645,  3666,  4275-6276,  1914,  4417-4419. 

93McGinnis  2010,  267;  Motoring  and  Boating.  1905,  209;  Power  Boat  News  1905b,  106. 

94 St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1 892f,h,  1 894d. 

95McGinnis  2010,  267-268;  Minneapolis  Journal  1905c-f;  Motoring  and  Boating  1905,  209;  Power  Boat  News  1905a,  53. 
96 Grand  Forks  Daily  Herald  1916. 

97USACE  1913,  3646,  1914,  4426-4428,  1917,  3928-3929. 


50 


Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat 
Cokato  Museum,  Cokato,  Wright  County 

History 

MHM  first  learned  of  the  Indian  Cokato  Boat  Works  (CBW)  when  visiting  the  Cokato 
Museum  in  December  201 3.98  Gordon  L.  Mattson  announced  the  establishment  of  the 
CBW  in  early  April  1948,  where  he  would  be  constructing  “cedar  strip  boats  in  12-foot, 
14-foot,  and  16-foot  sizes.  A year  later,  with  the  help  of  brother  Milton  Mattson,  CBW 
was  busy  making  custom-built  watercraft,  ordered  from  people  around  Minnesota,  Iowa, 
and  the  Dakotas.  The  vessels  were  constructed  using  ash,  oak,  and  cedar.  During  1949 
or  1950,  the  Mattson  brothers  erected  a new  Quonset  building  to  house  the  Cokato 
Boat  and  Cabinet  Works  on  land  owned  by  their  father,  John  Mattson,  on  Highway  12. 
Pictorial  evidence  of  the  inner  workings  of  the  CBW  suggests  the  company  produced 
boats  for  the  Larson  Boat  Company  of  Little  Falls  and  labeled  them  as  Larson 
watercraft.  Further,  another  CBW  vessel  named  Squirt  3 that  has  survived  was 
recognized  in  its  registration  information  as  a 1951  Larson  (Cokato  Enterprise  1948, 
1949;  Cokato  Museum;  Gary  Voggesser  to  Mike  Worcester,  personal  communication, 
August  16,  2016). 


98MHM  was  at  the  Cokato  Museum  to  document  and  take  a wood  sample  from  a dugout  canoe  for  the  Minnesota  Dugout 
Canoe  Project. 


51 


MHM  contends  that  the  CBW  took  a contract  from  Larson  to  construct  an  unknown 
number  of  boats  in  1950-1951,  stemming  from  the  complete  destruction  by  fire  of  the 
Larson  Boat  Works  in  Little  Falls  on  December  13,  1949.  In  1948,  Larson  produced 
1,700  wooden  boats  and  at  the  time  of  the  fire,  the  company  was  still  producing  large 
numbers  of  wooden  boats  - their  Falls  Flyer,  inboard  utilities,  and  outboard  fishing,  duck 
boats,  and  pleasure  craft  among  them.  Subsidiary  Larson  Water  Craft  Company 
produced  aluminum  vessels  in  a separate  factory  and  was  unharmed.  Larson  lost  3 
buildings,  400  wooden  boats,  and  many  more  were  damaged  in  the  fire  that  started  in 
the  wood  sanding  room.  The  fire  spread  quickly  due  to  large  amounts  of  flammable 
varnish,  paint,  and  wood.  It  is  unknown  how  many  watercraft  CBW  may  have  built  for 
Larson,  but  considering  the  CBW  apparently  only  constructed  about  40  watercraft,  it 
could  not  have  been  a large  number.  The  CBW  was  solvent  at  least  through  1952,  but 
by  1955,  apparently  the  brothers  were  no  longer  producing  boats.  Instead,  the  Mattson 
brothers  established  the  Mattson  Building  Company  that  specialized  in  constructing 
steel  farm  buildings  and  Quonset  huts  similar  to  the  one  that  formerly  housed  the  Boat 
Works.  Hand-crafting  small  wooden  cedar  strip  boats  was  labor-intensive  and 
expensive,  making  them  unprofitable  when  produced  on  a small  scale.  Only  one  other 
CBW  watercraft  is  known  to  survive,  beyond  the  Cokato  Museum  and  Voggesser 
examples,  owned  by  people  in  North  Dakota  (Brainerd  Daily  Dispatch  1949;  Cokato 
Museum;  Cokato  Enterprise  1955a-b;  Miller  2008;  Research  Division  1952,  10,  1955 
1 1 ; Sommers  2000,  21-30). 


Four  wooden  Larson  boats  in  the  Cokato  Boat  Works  factory  (Cokato  Mueum). 


52 


Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat 

MHM  documented  the  Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (COMB)  on  February  1 
and  22,  2017  at  the  Cokato  Museum.  Bruce  Reischl,  a restorer  of  boats  and  outboard 
motors,  came  across  the  boat  in  3 pieces  - used  as  shelves  - and  acquired  it.  In  2007- 
2008,  Mr.  Reischl  restored  the  boat  and  then  contacted  the  Cokato  Museum  to  inform 
the  organization  of  its  existence  (Miller  2008),  and  in  2012  Mr.  Reischl  donated  the 
COMB  to  the  museum.  The  COMB’s  wooden  hull  is  13.50  feet  long  and  14.00  feet  long 
overall  (including  the  bow  roller  and  anchor  lock),  4.50  feet  in  the  beam,  with  a 17.00- 
inch  depth  of  hold.  The  stem  consists  of  a rectangular  outer  stempost  that  is  curved  and 
attached  to  the  keel.  Large  bolts  driven  through  the  outer  stempost  attach  it  to  the  inner 
stempost  (not  seen).  An  anchor  roller  with  an  anchor  lock  is  attached  to  a bow  casting 
produced  specifically  for  Cokato  Boat  Works.  Joseph  P.  Fox’s  anchor  roller  and  lock 
patent  labeled  the  mechanism  as  a ‘rope  snubber’  (Fox  1943).  A screw  eye  attached  to 
the  stempost  and  serves  as  a tow  ring.  At  the  stern,  the  keel  s attached  to  the  hull 
bottom  and  protrudes  from  it,  square  in  cross-section.  The  gunwale  has  no  caprail  so 
the  futtocks  are  visible  between  the  narrow  beams  that  comprise  the  gunwale;  the  outer 
beam  acts  as  a rubrail.  Splashrails  run  along  the  entire  length  of  the  COMB  on  port  and 
starboard.  The  hull  is  comprised  of  thin  cedar  wood  strip  strakes  joined  end  to  end, 
making  it  carvel-built.  The  vessel  has  a wide  flat  bottom,  and  the  aft  section  of  the  boat 
has  slight  tumblehome,  where  the  hull  narrows  from  the  waterline  to  the  gunwale.  The 
square  transom,  designed  to  take  an  outboard  motor,  is  comprised  of  1 wide  plank  with 
a thin  caprail;  it  has  2 metal  carrying  handles  and  red  reflectors  attached.  The  transom 


53 


plate,  a rectangular  metal  piece  that  enhances  the  transom’s  strength  when  the  motor  is 
on  the  boat,  is  attached  to  the  inner  transom  face. 


Left:  The  Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  is  three  pieces  at  the  beginning  of  the  restoration 
process.  Right:  the  reunited  hull  (Bruce  Reichl,  on  file  at  the  Cokato  Museum). 


The  Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (MHM). 

Inside  the  hull  at  the  transom,  a centerline  knee  is  attached  to  the  boat’s  bottom  and 
adds  strength  to  the  stern.  Two  horizontal  metal  knees  on  the  port  and  starboard 
quarters  on  top  of  the  gunwale  also  add  strength.  The  COMB  has  thin  frames  attached 
to  the  inner  hull,  providing  rigidity  to  the  vessel.  Each  frame  is  one  long  thin  piece  of 
wood  that  has  been  curved  into  a wide  U shape.  One  short  longitudinal  stringer  is 
attached  to  the  hull  bottom  near  the  boat  and  2 longitudinal  stringers  attached  to  the 
futtocks  on  both  sides  extending  from  the  stern  quarters  to  the  bow.  Four  bench  seats 
rest  on  the  longitudinal  stringer,  1 in  the  bow,  2 amidships,  and  1 in  the  stern.  The  aft 
amidships  bench  also  has  metal  brackets,  port  and  starboard,  as  additional  attachment 
points  to  the  gunwale.  There  are  4 metal  oarlocks,  2 on  each  side,  aligned  with  the  2 


54 


amidships  benches.  The  watercraft  is  primarily  held  together  with  small  bronze  nails 
enhanced  by  slot  head  screws  and  a few  Phillips  head  screws  in  certain  areas.  The 
bottom  of  the  hull  to  just  after  the  turn  of  the  bilge,  under  the  splashrails,  is  painted  dark 
green  and  the  entire  hull  has  a high  varnish  finish. 


The  Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (MHM). 

The  current  registration  number  painted  on  both  sides  of  the  bow  is  MN  0102  KH  and  it 
expired  in  2013.  This  number  in  the  “K”  range  is  in  a group  of  numbers  reserved  for 
vessels  such  as  rowboats,  canoes,  and  sailboats  that  can  operate  with  motors,  but  have 
the  options  of  oar  or  sail  propulsion  as  well.  The  information  in  DNR  records  reflects  the 
nature  of  the  boat:  “14’  Cokato  1950,  made  of  wood,  last  registered  12/31/2013”  (John 
Nordby,  personal  communication,  March  6,  2017).  However,  this  information  is  only 
partially  correct,  stemming  from  the  fact  that  the  boat  was  taken  out  of  commission  and 
cut  into  3 pieces  for  a time.  The  original  registration  number  for  the  COMB,  shown  in 
images  taken  during  her  restoration,  was  MN  1792  AC.  This  number  was  assigned  to 
the  boat  in  1959,  when  the  State  of  Minnesota  first  required  motor  boat  registrations. 
The  DNR  information  attached  to  this  license  number:  “14’  Home  1952,  last  registered 
12/31/1994”  (John  Nordby,  personal  communication,  March  6,  2017).  This  information  is 
helpful,  since  it  reveals  that  the  owner  of  the  COMB  listed  her  as  a ‘home  build’  and  not 
the  CBW  - regardless  of  the  fact  that  “Cokato  Boat  Wks.  Cokato,  Minn.”  is  impressed 
into  the  bow  casting  - or  did  not  think  it  was  important.  Whether  the  boat  was 
constructed  in  1950  or  1952  cannot  be  determined  at  this  time.  Lastly,  Mr.  Reischl’s  fine 
restoration  work  can  be  discerned  due  to  the  use  of  wood  of  a lighter  shade  in  those 
places  where  he  combined  the  3 hull  pieces  into  one  skillfully  integrated  whole  - a 
proper  act  of  conservation  and  restoration  of  the  COMB. 


I 


55 


Left:  The  current  registration 
number  on  the  boat  (MHM). 

MHM’s  3D  scans  of  the  Cokato  Boat 
Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat.  The 
scanning  process  included  several 
scans  saved  as  separate  files. 
Because  of  the  vagaries  in  lighting, 
the  color  version  of  the  scanned 
images  appears  like  a patchwork 
(below). 


56 


Herter’s  Model  St.  Lawrence  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (1 988.338.1. A-C) 

Minnesota  Historical  Society,  St.  Paul,  Ramsey  County 

History 

MHM  first  learned  of  the  Herter’s  Model  St.  Lawrence  Outboard  Motor  Boat  (HSL)  when 
visiting  the  Minnesota  Historical  Society  (MNHS)  warehouse  in  January  2014." 
Herter’s,  Inc.,  established  in  1937  by  George  Herter,  initially  occupied  the  upper  level  of 
his  father’s  dry  goods  store  in  Waseca.  Growing  during  the  1940s,  Herter’s 
manufactured  and  sold  a variety  of  hunting  equipment  (including  firearms  and 
ammunition),  fishing  tackle,  decoys,  other  types  of  sporting  goods,  and  soon  - boats  - 
by  mail  order  catalog.  The  company  opened  7 brick  and  mortar  stores100,  but  over  the 
decades  the  company  was  primarily  known  for  its  mail  order  business  and  quirky 
catalogs,  written  by  George  Herter  with  his  “Barnum-esque”  language.  This  habit  is 
reflected  in  the  description  of  “Herter’s  Aircraft  Division,  Inc.  - World’s  largest  suppliers 
of  aircraft,  air  missile  and  air  target  liquid  glass  resins”.  Also,  Herter  proudly  claimed 
many  of  his  products  had  earned  the  endorsement  of  the  ‘North  Star  Guides 
Association’  - an  organization  that  was  a figment  of  his  imagination.  Further,  Herter’s 
catalogs  and  several  custom-casted  metal  products  claimed  the  company  was 
established  in  1893  - the  year  Edward  O.  Herter  founded  his  store  in  Waseca  - and  not 
in  1937.  Regardless  of  fantastic  claims,  it  is  fact  that  a Waseca  company’s  production  of 
400,000-500,000  Herter’s  catalogs  per  order  made  it  one  of  the  busiest  US  commercial 
printing  firms.  Herter’s  other  publications  considered  a variety  of  topics,  including  a 
recipe  book  that  had  15  editions  and  Hitler’s  omelet  recipe,  he  claimed.  Herter’s  has 
been  characterized  as  “the  Sears,  Roebuck  of  the  outdoor  industry.. .[and]  was  the 
inspiration  for  today’s  huge  mail  order  and  big-box  outdoor  retailers”.  This  moniker  is 
helpful  to  place  Herter’s  in  an  historical  context  as  an  innovator  in  American  commerce. 
However,  over-extension  and  other  circumstances  pushed  the  company  into  bankruptcy 
in  1977.  Cabela’s  acquired  the  Herter’s  brand  and  it  still  embosses  ammunition  boxes 
and  other  products  (Collins  2008;  Copyright  Office  1957,  1118;  Smith  2015). 


Left:  USGS  Map  of  Waseca  with  the 
Herter’s,  Inc.  factory  circled  in  red 
(1964).  Below:  Aerial  image  of  the 
Herter’s  factory  in  July  1951  (John  R. 
Borchert  Map  Library) 


MHM  was  at  the  MNHS  to  document  and  take  a wood  sample  from  a dugout  canoe  for  the  Minnesota  Dugout  Canoe  Project. 
100The  stores  were  located  in  Waseca  and  Glenwood,  MN,  Mitchell,  SD,  Beaver  Dam,  Wl,  Iowa  City  and  Iowa  Falls,  IA,  and  in 
Olympia,  WA. 


57 


Herter’s  Boats  and  Boat-Building  Supplies 

By  1949  the  company  sold  boat-making  supplies,  including  “Herter’s  Famous  Blue 
Prints”  for  several  types  of  wooden  fishing  and  hunting  boats  - and  water  shoes.  Water 
shoes  appear  to  be  thin  wooden  planks  attached  to  the  feet  and  designed  “by  a foreign 
power  for  moving  fully  equipped  troops  quickly  and  safely  over  inland  water  and 
swamps”.  Further,  by  1951  the  company  sold  and  advertised  “new  life  for  old  boats”, 
promoting  the  sale  and  use  of  fiberglass  fabric  and  resin  to  preserve  and  protect 
wooden  hulls.  Herter’s  further  touted  their  fiberglass  application  process  with  claims  that 
their  “Fiberglas  has  5 times  the  tensile  strength  of  steel. ..will  stop  a bullet,  is  rotproof, 
wormproof,  corrosionproof,  non-deteriorating,  permanently  colored  if  desired”.  Other 
watercraft-related  supplies  in  Herter’s  catalogs  include  their  “Famous  Dull  Duck  Boat 
Paint”,  “Famous  Concentrated  Marine  Boat  Cement  and  Crack  Repairer”,  marine  glue, 
and  canvas  waterproofer,  filler,  and  shrinker,  fiberglass  hull  patching  kits,  metal  safety 
boat  stabilizers,  metal  oarlocks,  wooden  oars  and  copper  oar  tips.  By  1954,  Herter’s 
promotion  of  their  chrome  fiberglass  cloth  and  liquid  glass  led  to  the  production  of  their 
own  line  of  watercraft  - using  wood  or  chrome  fiberglass  to  construct  the  hulls  (Herter’s 
Inc.  1949,  74-77,  1951,  37-43;  Motor  Boating  1952a,  120-121,  1952b,  104,  1954,  379). 


\ # Herter  * lhe  «nl> 

\ j-las  p^cet^  laH  proce^  f lhc  Oernxnt 

“M'  Naw.  .»«>  ** 

\ & «»y  »*•«  ‘ - 

\ 9 Reliable-  * * ' A I 


Corp*-  | i0«esl  »n  r°  *eulVt*  . 

*525.  or 

fiive  vouf  \io«rs  °r  ' ; if  in  2 W ^ - 1 

Her,rr  f,h\ 

UrKriorof'K- 

rowonprooi.  o® 

WL 

today- 


CHROME  FIBERGLAS  CLOTH 
and  LIQUID  GLASS 

BOAT  COVERING  and  MAKING 


BUY  DIRECT  AT  WHOLESALE  PRICES! 


195' 


GUARANTEED  LOWEST  PRICES. 
WORLD'S  LARGEST  SUPPLIERS. 
WRITE  TODAY  FOR  HUGE 
NEW  CATALOG  NO.  ANK 


J 


HERTER’S  SST  f£s  "««•*  Mi""“8’0 


GUARANTEED  SOLD  AT  LESS 
THAN  WHOLESALE  PRICES 

9 14  ft.  Takes  outboards  up  to  25  Horsepower.  Made  of 
Owens  Corning  fiberglas  and  duraluminum.  Made  in  off 
season  to  give  work  to  decoy  plant.  nfl 

Guaranteed  $600.00  value.  May  be  left 
outside  the  year  around.  Uncondition- 
ally guaranteed.  y*  FOB  Waseca 


Herter’s  advertisements  promoting  boats  and  boat 
maintenance  products  (Motor  Boat  1952,  Motorboating 
1954,  379,  Popular  Science  1957,  85,  1959,  245 

1 Jshd  \^L«clT:^NA.^t>^s 


WRITE  FOR  CATALOG  DEPT.  CAFW 

LUHERTER'S  Vaseca,  Minn.  Since  1893 


\ U.S€D  8Y  ARMY'  navy  and  marines 

\\  a ^ow  Cost— Apply  fa  #e>M  ft  r | 

* ■ • "•  «*  cu,!,ZL  I 

COMBAT  AIRPLANES  AUTff  r PROOF  VESTS, 

B°DIES 


HERTER’S 

WASECA,  MlNNFQnTA 


58 


The  Waseca  factory’s  address  was  1 I6V2  State  Street  in  Waseca  by  1949  (and  possibly 
earlier),  was  registered  with  the  State  of  Minnesota  as  the  ‘Herter’s  Hunting  Equipment 
Plant’  in  1952  and  1955,  described  as  a company  manufacturing  “fishing  tackle  and 
hunting  equipment,  including  decoys”  - no  mention  of  boats  specifically.  However,  in 
1956  Herter’s  published  a detailed  account  of  their  chrome  fiberglass  process  that 
plated  spun  fiberglass  with  chrome.  Herter’s  produced  fiberglass  by  melting  glass 
marbles,  subjecting  the  liquid  glass  to  air  blowers  to  form  the  melted  glass  into  filaments 
that  were  wound  around  a drum,  and  then  the  fibers  were  brought  together  into  one 
thread  and  collected  onto  spools.  The  spools  were  heated  to  remove  starch  and  at  this 
point,  the  glass  fibers  were  coated  with  chrome  that  “gives  the  glass  fibers  a permanent 
coat  which  tends  to  shed  moisture  and  most  important  of  all  makes  the  Resinote101 
when  applied  stick  tightly  to  the  glass.  Herter’s  evidence  that  chrome  fiberglass  boats 
were  made  from  “the  one  material  from  which  the  best  boats  are  being  built”  was  the 
acceptance  by  the  US  Navy,  Army,  Air  Force,  and  Marine  Corps  to  utilize  the  material  to 
manufacture  boats,  combat  helmets,  flak  jackets,  and  Infantry  combat  armor.  A Navy 
report  stated  that  chrome  fiberglass  “saturated  with  plastic  resins  simply  cannot  leak. 
The  only  water  that  can  come  in,  is  spray  or  rain. ..the  chrome  glass  fiber  laminated  hull 
will  not  stretch,  swell,  shrink,  or  otherwise  change  its  shape  or  increase  in  weight,  nor 
will  it  oxidize  (rust)”.  Further,  the  Navy  determined  that  the  smooth  hulls  increased  a 
boat’s  speed  and  the  lack  of  fasteners  - wood  screws  - enhanced  the  hull’s  strength. 
Two  test  boats,  one  partially  buried  on  a beach  for  1 year  and  other  left  to  soak  in  water 
- and  ice  during  the  winter  - for  2 years,  experienced  no  changes.  Herter’s  sold  chrome 
fiberglass  boat  covering  kits  through  the  specialized  catalog  - along  with  wood  and 
chrome  fiberglass  boats.  This  addition  to  the  company’s  manufacturing  enterprise  was 
reflected  in  their  1957  business  listing:  “Herter’s  Inc.,  George  L.  Herter,  fishing  tackle, 
gunstocks,  fly  tying  equipment,  shotgun  chokes  & ventilated  ribs,  reloading  equipment 
and  components,  decoys,  game  calls,  fiberglass  boats  & boat  coverings,  marine 
hardware”  (Herter’s  Inc.  1956,  3-4;  Research  Division  1949,  204,  1952,  68,  1955,  65, 
1957,  61). 


The  Herter’s,  Inc.  factory 
complex  still  exists  south  of 
downtown  Waseca  (Google 
Earth  2015). 


101 


Resinote  is  Herter’s  own  brand  of  resin  used  to  manufacture  fiberglass  boats. 


59 


Therefore,  Herter’s,  Inc.  began  manufacturing  boats  in  their  Waseca  factory  in  1956. 
That  year,  the  company  offered  5 open  hull  chrome  fiberglass  outboard  motor  boat 
models:  Canada  (12  foot),  Hudson  Bay  (14  foot),  Manitoba  (14  foot),  St.  Lawrence  (16 
foot),  and  Quebec  (16  foot).  Herter’s  also  offered  the  hulls  of  the  Canada,  Hudson  Bay, 
and  Quebec  models  without  the  aluminum  benches,  gunwales,  stringers,  and  other 
fittings,  intended  for  customers  who  preferred  to  customize  their  boats,  or  use  them  as 
molds  to  create  their  own  fiberglass  vessels.  Models  Hudson  Bay  and  Quebec  could  be 
ordered  with  a ‘duraluminum’1®  foredeck  and  lifting  handle  or  an  amidships  deck  for  an 
additional  charge.  Models  Manitoba  and  St.  Lawrence  have  deeper  hulls  and  are  wider 
in  the  beam  than  the  Canada,  Hudson  Bay,  and  Quebec  models.  The  open  hulled 
chrome  fiberglass  models  had  duraluminum  fittings,  including  hollow  keels,  benches, 
stringers,  and  extruded  duraluminum  gunwales.  All  5 models  could  be  painted  tanager 
red,  jet  black,  or  marine  green  for  an  additional  cost  - otherwise  the  chrome  fiberglass 
hulls  were  delivered  in  their  post-production  translucent  state  (Herter’s  Inc.  1956,  23-29). 


HEAVY  DUTY  "*  A Better 


°VER,^7.Vy  WEIGHT  CHROMt  ' 

EAVY  DUTY  V/EIG  A Better  Boat  ForUj 

Read  Carefully  YouWi — — ==:— 

HERTER'S  CHROME  FIBERGLAS  MODEL  MANITOBA 

AND  MODEL  ST.  LAWRENCE 


Herter’s  specialized  catalog 
featured  images  and  long 
explanations  about  why  everyone 
should  buy  their  boats  or  use  their 
chrome  fiberglass  to  fix  their  boats 
(Herter’s,  Inc.  1956,  10,  24-26, 
digitized  by  MHM). 


PHOTOGRAPH  OF  OUR  CHROME  FIBERGLAS  MODEL 
QUEBEC  HULL  DESIGN 


Photograph  of  Model  SL  Lawrence  on  the  Water. 


Photo  No.  1 shows  the  unique  aircraft  type  bracing  * 
the  bottom  that  gives  strength  without  weight  Note 
the  number  of  Navy  Epofoam  Plastic  filled  flotation  tacit* 
for  positive  buoyancy  under  any  condition. 

HERTER'S  INC.,  WASECA,  MINNESOTA,  U.  S-  A 


PHOTOGRAPH  OF  OUR  CHROME  FIBERGLAS 
MODEL  HUDSON  BAY  ON  THE  WATER 

This  photograph  is  not  very  good  as  it  was  taken  on 
an  overcast  day,  but  it  does  show  some  of  the  beautiful  lines 
and  manner  in  which  our  boats  perform. 


Photo  No.  2.  Model  Hudson  Bay 


102 


Duraluminum  was  a trade  name  for  an  early  form  of  aluminum  alloy.  See  pages  65-67  for  examples  of  Herter’s  boats. 


60 


Also  in  1956,  limited  numbers  of  Herter’s  outboard  runabout  models  Mark  III  (14  foot) 
and  Mark  IX  (16  foot)  were  offered  for  sale.  These  chrome  fiberglass  boats  had 
foredecks,  steering  wheels,  and  2 cockpits.  Herter  compared  their  sportier  boat,  the 
“Duofoil  World  Famous  Flying  Fish  Runabout”,  to  a spaceship  with  its  chrome  fiberglass 
hull,  duraluminum  fittings,  and  port  and  starboard  fins.  Double-ended  and  square  stern 
canoes,  as  well  as  duck  and  goose  boats,  rounded  out  the  10  models  of  chrome 
fiberglass  watercraft  offered  for  sale  in  1956  (Herter’s  Inc.  1956,  25-26). 


HERTER'S  CHROME  FIBERGLAS  DUOFOIL  WORLD 
FAMOUS  FLYING  FISH  RUNABOUT 
MEASUREMENTS  AND  PRICES 

Although  this  famous  runabout  looks  like  a space  ship 
its  design  is  time  proven.  It  is  actually  a composite  of  the 
two  fastest  boats  in  the  world  which  in  turn  represent  the 
latest  in  proven  marine  design  to  date. 

The  forward  part  of  the  Flying  Fish  uses  the  proven 
design  principles  of  the  boat  Slo-Mo-Shun,  North  America’s 
fastest  boat  and  safest  high  speed  boat.  The  rear  of  the  hull 
uses  the  design  principles  of  the  English  Bluebird  boat,  the 
fastest  and  safest  European  fast  boat. 

The  hull  and  deck  are  chrome  fiberglas.  The  gunwales, 
sprayrails  and  keel  are  strong  duraluminum.  The  prow 
piece  is  hand  cast  duraluminum  and  has  a built  in  stream- 
lined handle. 


Side  and  Top  View 


Right:  Herter’s 
Mark  III  and  IX 
in  1956 
(Herter’s,  Inc. 
1956,  25). 


HERTER'S  CHROME  FIBERGLAS  MARK  III  AND 
MARK  IX  RUNABOUTS.  $900  RUNABOUTS 
FOR  $267.00 

We  will  produce  only  a very  few  Mark  III  and  Mark 
fX  runabouts  this  year  as  we  produce  them  only  to  keep 
some  of  our  good  employees  during  off  seasons  and  most 
of  this  time  will  go  to  our  regular  Chrome  Fiberglas  boats. 


The  Herter’s  Spaceship,  the  Duofoil  World  Famous  Flying  Fish  Runabout,  owned  by  the  Jetsons 

(Herter’s,  Inc.  1956,  26;  Woodyboater.com). 

However,  Herter’s  1956  watercraft  manufacturing  team  also  offered  wooden  boats  to 
their  customers  who  preferred  wood  instead  of  fiberglass.  MHM  suspects  the  thinness  - 
and  the  translucent  nature  of  the  un-painted  examples  - of  the  entirely  chrome 
fiberglass  hulls  might  have  not  inspired  confidence  in  some  sportsmen  and  pleasure 
boaters.  The  wooden  boats  were  constructed  of  marine  plywood,  white  oak,  or 
mahogany,  and  were  shipped  with  a chrome  fiberglass  kit  with  enough  material  for  the 
new  owner  to  cover  the  wooden  vessel:  models  Fort  Francis  Voyageur  (12  foot),  Sioux 
Duck  Boat  (12  foot),  Winnebago  Rice  Boat  (12  foot),  and  Cree  Pike  (14  foot).  Herter’s 
also  sold  boat  trailers  to  accommodate  16  foot  long  boats  or  less,  canvas  boat  covers, 
oars,  cleats,  chocks,  oarlocks,  anchors,  bow  rollers,  bow  lights,  spotlights,  steering 
wheels,  throttle  controllers  and  cables,  detachable  seats,  carrying  handles,  transom 
plates,  outboard  motor  locks,  anchor  lines,  hull  bumpers  - and  the  list  goes  on,  right  to 
pennants  and  flags.  Lastly,  the  company  still  sold  watercraft  blue  prints,  first  offered  in 
1949  (Herter’s  Inc.  1956,  30-47).  In  1957,  Herter’s  continued  to  manufacture  the  open 
hull  chrome  fiberglass  watercraft  with  the  translucent  hulls  (Hudson  Bay,  Quebec, 
Canada,  Manitoba,  St.  Lawrence)  and  expanded  the  choices  of  sporty  chrome 


61 


fiberglass  and  duraluminum  runabouts:  Mark  III,  Mark  IV,  Mark  IX,  Flying  Fish,  and  El 
Dorado  Rocket.  The  port  and  starboard  quarter  fins  on  the  Flying  Fish  and  El  Dorado 
Rocket  grew  larger  and  larger  after  1956  (Knauff  ND).103 

Herter’s  Model  St.  Lawrence  Outboard  Motor  Boat 

MHM  documented  the  HSL  on  February  8,  15,  17,  and  March  1,  8 and  22,  2017  at  the 
MNHS  warehouse.  The  HSL’s  hull  is  15.50  feet  long,  64.50  inches  in  the  beam,  with  a 
25.00-inch  depth  of  hold,  and  a wide  flat  bottom.  Herter’s  listed  the  length  of  the  HSL  as 
16.00  feet  long  and  64.00  inches  wide  (Herter’s  1956,  26).  The  .50-inch  beam  and  part 
of  the  6.00-inch  hull  length  difference  are  attributed  to  the  warping  of  the  starboard  side 
of  the  hull  that  has  affected  the  length  and  beam  of  the  watercraft.  However,  the 
warping  does  not  account  for  more  than  1.0-inch  of  the  difference;  MHM  attributes  the 
other  5.00  inches  to  the  habit  of  boat-builders  to  often  round-up  hull  length 
measurements.  The  chrome  fiberglass  hull  was  formed  using  the  female  mold  method; 
the  fiberglass  fabric  was  laid  over  the  mold  and  covered  with  resin  to  form  it  to  the  mold 
and  harden  the  cloth.  An  extruded  duraluminum  gunwale  and  hollow  keel  help  with  hull 
rigidity.  Four  angle  sockets  attached  to  the  gunwale  were  designed  to  take  the  French 
Canadian  oarlocks  that  are  attached  to  the  2 wooden  oars  associated  with  the  boat 
(Herter  1956,  34).  It  is  unknown  if  the  oars  are  original  to  this  boat,  although  the 
oarlocks  are  of  Herter’s  manufacture.  Two  longitudinal  duraluminum  stringers  attached 
to  the  inner  hull  bottom  on  both  port  and  starboard  are  connected  to  each  other  with  5 
floor-like  athwartships  braces.  The  HSL  has  4 duraluminum  benches  with  8 seat  braces 
that  attach  them  to  the  gunwale  on  both  port  and  starboard.104  The  gunwale  supports 
the  small  front  seat  bench,  but  3 stanchions  attached  to  the  floor-like  braces  hold  up  the 
3 aft-most  benches.  Under  each  bench,  ‘air  tank’  chambers  are  formed  of  square  U- 
shaped  duraluminum,  each  filled  with  rectangular  pieces  of  ‘Navy  Epofoam  plastic’  - 
flotation  foam  (Herter’s  1956,  23).  A stern  knee105  attached  to  the  inner  hull  bottom 
provides  rigidity  and  stability  at  the  transom.  The  top  edge  of  the  knee  is  inter-locked 
with  a neoprene  and  aluminum  transom  plate  and  caprail  that  Herter’s  claimed  was 
“quiet,  vibration  proof  with  all  motors.  Unconditionally  guaranteed  the  quietest,  most 
vibration  free  boat  in  the  world”  (Herter’s  1956,  22).  Stern  castings  with  carrying  handles 
attached  at  the  gunwale  level  on  port  and  starboard  provide  further  strength.  Hollow 
duraluminum  splashrails  are  attached  to  the  outer  hull  on  port  and  starboard.  The  HSL 
has  a bow  casting  with  a handle  and  an  optional  bow  eye  bolt  that  would  serve  as  a 
towing  ring  or  anchor  line  guide. 


MHM’s  Kelly  Nehowig  and 
Christopher  Olson  measuring 
the  Herter’s  Model  St. 
Lawrence  (MHM). 


103  See  pages  65-67  for  examples  of  Herter’s  boats. 

104The  Herter’s  catalog  labels  the  seat  brace  “American  Type  Made  of  Galvanized  Rustproof  Steel”  (Herter’s  1956,  36). 
105The  Herter’s  catalog  labeled  the  stern  knee  a “Hand  Made  English  Type  Streamline  Transom  Knee”  (Herter’s  1956,  36). 


62 


Scuffs  and  marks  are  indicators  of  wear  on  the  hull  over  the  decades.  At  the  starboard 
quarter  inside  the  hull,  rust  stains  indicate  the  location  of  the  gas  stank  for  the  outboard 
motor.  On  the  starboard  side  amidships  at  the  turn  of  the  bilge,  a 2-layered  square 
patch  of  fiberglass  and  resin  represents  a hull  repair.  Larger  and  more  obvious  repairs 
are  located  on  the  port  transom.  A long  rectangular  unpainted  fiberglass  patch  is 
applied  to  the  outer  hull  at  the  junction  of  the  transom  and  the  port  side.  On  the  port  side 
transom,  another  repair  is  comprised  of  2 fiberglass  strips  sealed  to  the  hull  with  white 
resin  or  caulking,  and  left  unpainted.  The  junction  repair  provides  helpful  evidence 
pertaining  to  the  working  life  of  the  HSL  because  it  is  applied  under  the  port  side 
splashrail.  This  detail  confirms  that  whomever  conducted  the  maintenance  on  the  HSL 
removed  the  splashrail  during  the  process  and  this  information  is  significant  because  of 
the  boat’s  hull  color.  When  manufactured,  Herter’s  chrome  fiberglass  boats  were 
translucent,  but  the  factory  would  paint  the  hull  for  an  additional  cost.  According  to  DNR 
records,  the  HSL  was  constructed  in  1956  (John  Nordby,  personal  communication, 


63 


March  6,  2017),  the  first  year  that  Herter’s  constructed  boats.  However,  Herter’s  offered 
3 hull  colors  for  Model  St.  Lawrence  in  1956:  jet  black,  marine  green,  and  tanager  red. 
The  HSL  hull  color,  however,  does  coincide  with  one  offered  by  Herter’s  at  least  by 
1969;  it  is  called  ‘dead  grass’.  MHM  suggests  the  boat  might  have  been  translucent  for 
many  years  and  the  owners  purchased  a supply  of  dead  grass  paint  from  Herter’s  and 
painted  it  themselves.  One  piece  of  evidence  supporting  this  theory  is  the  uneven 
application  of  the  paint  in  some  places  on  the  outer  hull,  where  it  has  nearly  worn  off. 
Regardless,  whoever  painted  the  boat  after  it  left  the  factory  took  care  to  remove  the 
metal  attributes  prior  to  painting  the  hull. 


Repairs  to  the  hull  of  the  Model  St.  Lawrence 
(MHM). 


HERTER  BOAT  COLORS 


Teal  Blue  Tanager  Red  Marine  Green  Gull  While 


Navy  Blue  Wine  Dead  Gnm  $«a  Gr**n 


A Herter’s  Boat  Color  Chart 
(Herter’s,  Inc.  1969). 


Jet  Black  Dark  Brown  Live  Rush 


The  HSL’s  registration  number,  seen  on  the  starboard  and  port  bow,  is  MN  4042  AB; 
this  number  was  assigned  to  the  boat  in  1959  when  the  State  of  Minnesota  first  required 
motor  boat  registrations.  An  aluminum  plaque  attached  to  the  inner  hull  on  the  port  side 
forward  says  ‘MINNESOTA  LICENSED  BOAT  PERMANENT  NO.  51896  DO  NOT 
OVERLOAD  BE  SAFE  STAY  WITH  BOAT’;  the  origin  of  this  metal  plate  is  unknown. 
Other  on-hull  evidence  recording  the  life  of  the  HSL  includes  remnants  of  older 
Minnesota-shaped  year  validation  stickers  near  the  registration  number,  including 
orange  (1977-78-79),  yellow  (1980-81-82),  and  blue  (1983-84-85).  The  latest  sticker,  a 


64 


1988  light-colored  square,  confirms  the  DNR  records:  “16’  Herters  1956,  made  of 
fiberglass,  last  registered  12/31/1988”  (John  Nordby,  personal  communication,  April  6, 
2017).  Over  the  decades,  the  hull’s  registration  number  has  been  applied  and  re-applied 
to  the  hull  as  evidenced  by  a surviving  ‘4’  decal  underneath  the  ‘N’  on  the  port  side  and 
the  outlines  of  other  numbers  as  well.  The  latest  registration  decals  were  adhered  to 
rectangular  plexiglass  pieces  that  are  attached  to  the  port  and  starboard  bow  with 
screws.  Interestingly,  the  port  side  plexiglass  piece  has  trapped  dried  leaves  and  other 
detritus  underneath  it;  MHM  contends  the  owners  applied  the  plexiglass  in  the  Spring  of 
1986  when  the  square  sticker  was  valid,  after  leaving  the  hull  outside  since  the  autumn 
of  1985.  Lastly,  the  bow  casting  of  the  HSL  has  proven  to  be  from  a different  model  of 
Herter’s  boat  - a Model  Hudson  Bay.  Hudson  Bay  chrome  fiberglass  boats  were  14.00 
feet  long,  55.00  inches  in  the  beam,  and  20.00-inch  deep  - much  different  than  the 
HSL.  Further,  the  Model  Quebec  was  16.00  feet  long  like  the  HSL,  but  had  a 56.00-inch 
beam  and  was  23.00-inch  deep  - much  less  substantial  than  the  HSL  (Herter’s  1956, 
24).  The  HSL  spent  over  4 decades  on  the  waters  of  Lake  Minnetonka  in  Hennepin  and 
Carver  Counties,  and  East  Fox  Lake  in  Crow  Wing  County  before  its  donation  to  the 
MNHS  in  1988  (MNHS  1988). 


Above:  The  Herter’s 
Model  St.  Lawrence’s 
registration  number  and 
identification  plaque 
(MHM). 


Left:  The  bow  casting 
that  says  “Model 
Hudson  Bay”  instead  of 
“Model  St.  Lawrence” 
(MHM). 


65 


MHM’s  3D  scans  of  the  Herter’s  Model 
St.  Lawrence  Outboard  Motor  Boat. 
The  scanning  process  included  several 
scans  saved  as  separate  files. 
Because  of  the  vagaries  in  lighting,  the 
color  version  of  the  scanned  images 
appears  like  a patchwork  (left  and 
below). 


Examples  of  Herter’s,  Inc.  Boats 
Model  St.  Lawrence 


66 


offerup.com 


Model  Hudson  Bay 


jlyforums.com 


1959 

smartmarineguide.com 


Waseca  County  Historical  Society 
(Joan  Mooney) 


67 


Model  Quebec  Model  Goose-Duck 


Mark  V Runabout  Flying  Fish  Standard 


forums.iboats.com  ronsusser.com 


Duofoil  World  Famous  Flying  Fish  Runabout 


forgottenfiberglass.com 


68 


Duofoil  World  Famous  Flying  Fish  Runabout 


El  Dorado  Rocket  Runabout 


69 


Conclusions 

To  more  fully  understand  the  cultural  information  5 small  watercraft  documented  during 
the  MSC  Project  provides,  it  is  helpful  to  consider  the  boats  within  their  historical 
contexts.  The  Ramaley  Boat  Company  was  a prolific  and  long-established  boat  works  at 
the  time  of  the  FFRB’s  construction.  Combining  the  inventory  and  facilities  of  the  Moore 
Boat  Works  on  Lake  Minnetonka  in  Wayzata  in  1912  strengthened  Ramaley’s  business 
in  Hennepin  County.  Historical  records  pertaining  to  Ramaley-built  boats,  particularly 
photographs  and  surviving  catalogs  - along  with  the  nautical  archaeological  record  - 
reveal  the  wide  range  of  vessel  types  the  company  designed  and  constructed.  The 
diversity  of  boat  designs  offered  by  the  company  indicates  their  broad  customer  base: 
fishermen,  hunters,  sail  and  motor  pleasure  boaters,  sail  and  motor  racers,  and 
houseboat  enthusiasts.  The  FFRB,  as  one  of  the  simpler  forms  of  Ramaley  vessel,  is 
one  of  the  most-overlooked  historic  watercraft:  a small  wooden  fishing  boat.  Small 
wooden  fishing  boats  of  the  19th  and  early  20th  Centuries  undoubtedly  out-numbered  all 
other  types  and  sizes  of  watercraft  built  in  Minnesota.  The  basic  commonality  of  small 
wooden  boats,  and  often  the  lower  quality  of  wood  that  comprised  the  hulls,  has  led  to  a 
dearth  of  this  vessel  type  in  museum  collections.  However,  as  MHM  conducts 
underwater  archaeological  investigations  in  more  Minnesota  lakes,  additional  small 
boats  will  be  identified  - preserved  on  the  bottoms  of  our  cold  freshwater  lakes. 
Additionally,  at  least  one  larger  Ramaley-built  boat  is  an  identified  wreck  on  the  bottom 
of  Lake  Minnetonka  - the  Ramaley  Family  Motor  Boat  Wreck  (21-HE-490)  - adding  to 
the  body  of  known  Ramaley  watercraft  to  still  exist. 

A crew  of  Mille  Lacs  Band  of  Ojibwe  boatwrights  constructed  the  IOMB  and  the 
craftsmanship  exhibited  in  the  hull’s  components  is  evident.  The  use  of  the  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works  vessels  within  the  business  of  the  Post  as  part  of  the  Lake 
Mille  Lacs  economy  was  a form  of  seasonally  sustainable  commerce.  The  Depression- 
era  employment  of  Mille  Lacs  Band  members  as  boatwrights,  painters,  and  fishing 
guides  benefited  the  people  locally.  Further,  the  sale  of  boats  beyond  Lake  Mille  Lacs 
strengthened  the  Ojibwe  economy  through  increased  production  - and  possibly  led  to 
the  survival  of  the  IOMB.  It  is  hoped  additional  products  of  the  Indian  Trading  Post  Boat 
Works  are  identified,  both  in  dry  storage  and  on  the  bottom  of  Minnesota’s  lakes. 
Regardless  of  decades  of  storage  in  an  uncontrolled  environment,  the  IOMB  is  stable 
and  will  continue  to  survive  in  its  current  situation. 

Significant  numbers  of  antique  boat  collections  are  aware  of  the  long  history  of  the 
Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works  around  the  country,  particularly  the  story  of  the  Gerry  Lo. 
However,  few  Minnesotans  are  aware  of  the  Dingle  Boat  Works,  its  longevity,  the 
diversity  of  the  watercraft  it  designed  and  offered  for  sale  - and  how  few  Dingle-built 
vessels  have  survived.  During  the  maritime  historical  research  process,  MHM  was 
impressed  by  the  prolific  nature  of  the  company,  particularly  their  design  and  production 
of  fast  catboat  and  sloop  racing  yachts  and  motor  ‘auto’  racing  boats.  From  row  boats  to 
sailboats  to  power  racers  to  houseboats  to  subchasers  to  towboats,  three  generations 
of  the  Dingle  family  produced  well-designed  and  constructed  watercraft  on  the  banks  of 
the  Mississippi  River  in  St.  Paul  for  69  years.  During  the  MSC  Project,  MHM  confirmed 
the  survival  of  7 Dingle-built  vessels  and  until  recently,  6 of  them  were  still  in  Minnesota. 
To  date,  no  Dingle  wrecks  have  been  confirmed  and  identified  on  the  bottom  of  any  lake 
or  river  in  Minnesota  or  the  United  States.  With  these  facts  recognized,  the  continued 


70 


survival  of  the  DOMB  greatly  enhances  our  shared  maritime  history  and  in  its  current 
circumstances,  this  Minnesota  legacy  is  assured. 

The  three  known  examples  of  the  short-lived  Cokato  Boat  Works  watercraft  to  have 
survived,  out  of  the  40  or  so  small  vessels  the  company  produced,  greatly  enhance 
Minnesota’s  maritime  history.  The  Mattson  brother’s  brief  stint  into  boatbuilding 
produced  sturdy  and  good-looking  wooden  watercraft  at  a time  when  aluminum  and 
fiberglass  were  beginning  their  dominance  in  the  post-World  War  II  personal  watercraft 
market.  The  production  of  handcrafted  wooden  boats  on  a small  scale  was  impossible 
to  sustain  - regardless  of  the  probable  Larson  Boat  Company  subcontract  following  the 
1949  fire.  However,  the  continued  use  of  the  Cokato  Boat  Works  vessels  into  the  2010s 
is  a testament  to  their  quality  construction  and  design. 

Contrastingly,  Herter’s,  Inc.  produced  inexpensive  watercraft  in  a factory  setting, 
primarily  out  of  fiberglass.  Apparently  Herter’s  did  not  produce  a set  number  of 
watercraft  per  year  or  per  season,  regardless  of  their  catalog  offerings.  However,  the 
longevity  of  known  lightweight  Herter’s  chrome  fiberglass  boats  supports  the  maker’s 
contention  that  like  all  of  their  products,  their  watercraft  were  world  famous,  unsinkable, 
corrosion-proof,  and  rot-proof.  Herter’s,  Inc.  and  its  plethora  of  diverse  offerings  of 
sporting  goods  was  the  beginning  of  the  mail-order  catalog  industry  as  well  as  the  ‘big 
box’  nature  that  late  20th  Century  commercial  endeavors  would  adopt.  This  business 
practice  did  not  help  or  hinder  the  production  of  watercraft  since  Herter’s  produced 
boats  and  canoes  that  could  be  ordered  as  a base  model  or  with  additional  gear,  at  very 
cheap  prices. 

The  preservation  of  the  wooden-hulled  FFRB,  IOMB,  and  DOMB  into  the  21st  Century, 
at  ages  of  approximately  85-110  years  old,  is  a tribute  to  the  Ramaley,  Trading  Post, 
and  Dingle  firms,  and  the  significance  of  Minnesota  boat  building  and  design.  On  a 
smaller  scale,  the  COMB  represents  boat  design  and  construction  knowledge  at  a time 
when  that  ability  was  being  replace  by  technological  advancements.  On  the  other  hand, 
the  HSL  represents  one  of  the  ‘future’  conditions  of  boatbuilding;  not  in  innovative 
design  or  quality,  but  in  the  production  of  cheaper  watercraft  out  of  durable  materials. 
Further,  considering  the  great  numbers  of  boats  produced  by  the  long-lived  firms  of 
Ramaley,  Dingle,  and  Herter’s,  to  have  3 of  40  Cokato  Boat  Works  and  1 of  200  Indian 
Trading  Post  Boat  Works  examples  survive  is  fortunate  for  our  shared  maritime  cultural 
heritage.  Even  more  importantly,  the  donation  of  the  COMB  and  IOMB  - along  with  the 
FFRB,  DOMB,  and  HSL  - to  museums  guarantees  their  healthy  survival  in  perpetuity. 

Further,  the  3D  scanning  and  documentation  of  surviving  watercraft  assists  underwater 
archaeologists  in  identifying  wrecks  of  the  same  or  similar  manufacture  on  the  bottom  of 
Minnesota’s  lakes  and  rivers.  In  addition,  the  3D  scanning  of  complete  boats  and 
specific  components  and  attributes  is  useful  for  preservation,  conservation,  and 
restoration  purposes.  Also,  printing  examples  of  the  scanned  boats  in  3D  miniature  can 
augment  the  archival  record  of  each  object,  and  even  promote  a museum’s  collection  by 
offering  the  printed  models  as  gift  shop  kits,  complete  with  paint. 


71 


References 

Barron  County  Historical  Society.  ND.  Marine  Building.  https://www.barron 
countymuseum.com/about1  -cl  pip 

Bemidji  Daily  Pioneer.  1909,  16  April. 

Benjamin,  Fred  B.  1991 . Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  Oral  History  Project.  Transcript. 
Interviewed  by  Anthony  Godfrey.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St.  Paul,  MN 

Bismarck  Tribune.  1922,  6 July. 

Board  of  Park  Commissioners.  1901.  Tenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park 
Commissioners  of  the  City  of  Saint  Paul.  Pioneer  Press  Company:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1902.  Eleventh  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City  of 

Saint  Paul.  Pioneer  Press  Company:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1905.  Fourteenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City 

of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31st,  1904.  Review  Publishing 
Company:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1907.  Sixteenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City 

of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31,  1906.  Pioneer  Press 
Manufacturing  Departments:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1908.  Seventeenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the 

City  of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31,  1907.  Review  Publishing 
Company:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1909.  Eighteenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City 

of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31,  1908.  Review  Publishing 
Company:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1 91 0.  Nineteenth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City 

of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31st,  1909.  City  of  St.  Paul:  St.  Paul, 
MN. 

. 1911.  Twentieth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the  City 

of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31,  1910.  The  Pioneer  Company:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

. 1912.  Twenty-First  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Park  Commissioners  of  the 

City  of  St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  December  31,  1911.  McGill-Warner 
Company:  St.  Paul,  MN, 

Board  of  Water  Commissioners.  1906.  Twenty-Fourth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of 
Water  Commissioners  of  the  City  of  St.  Paul:  January  1,  1906.  The  Pioneer 
Press  Manufacturing  Departments:  St.  Paul,  MN. 


72 


. 1907.  Twenty-Fifth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Water  Commissioners  of  the 

City  of  St.  Paul:  January  1,  1907.  The  Pioneer  Press  Manufacturing 

Departments:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1908.  Twenty-Sixth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Water  Commissioners  of  the 

City  of  St.  Paul:  January  1,  1908.  The  Pioneer  Press  Manufacturing 
Departments:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1910.  Twenty-Eighth  Annual  Report  of  the  Board  of  Water  Commissioners  of  the 

City  of  St.  Paul:  January  1,  1910.  1910,  The  Pioneer  Press  Company:  St.  Paul, 
MN. 

Boating.  1907a,  February;  1907b,  June. 

Bowel,  Captain  William  D.  2004.  The  Story  of  the  16  Ft.  Dingle  Boat  Given  to  Capt.  Wm. 
D.  Bowell  Sr  by  Bud  Moeller.  On  file  at  the  Minnesota  Historical  Society, 
2004.82.1.A-F  Accession  File. 

Brainerd  Daily  Dispatch.  1929,  2 May;  1933,  3 August;  1945,  11  December;  1949,  13 
December. 

Broehl,  Jr.,  Wayne  G.  1992.  Cargill:  Trading  the  World’s  Grain.  University  Press  of  New 
England:  Hanover,  NH. 

Bureau  of  Navigation.  1923.  List  of  Merchant  Vessels  of  the  United  States.  Department 
of  Commerce,  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 

Caldwell,  Letitia  Bella.  1991.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  Oral  History  Project. 
Transcript.  Interviewed  by  Anthony  Godfrey.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

Castle,  Henry  A.  1912.  History  of  St.  Paul  and  Vicinity.  Vol.  III.  Lewis  Publishing 
Company:  Chicago,  IL  and  New  York,  NY. 

Chief  of  Engineers.  1912.  Report  of  the  Chief  of  Engineers  U.S.  Army  1912.  Part  3.  US 
Army  Corps  of  Engineers.  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 

. 1913.  Report  of  the  Chief  of  Engineers  U.S.  Army  1913.  Part  3.  US  Army  Corps 

of  Engineers.  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 

. 1914.  Report  of  the  Chief  of  Engineers  U.S.  Army  1914.  Part  3.  US  Army  Corps 

of  Engineers.  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 

. 1915.  Report  of  the  Chief  of  Engineers  U.S.  Army  1915.  Part  3.  US  Army  Corps 

of  Engineers.  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 

. 1917.  Report  of  the  Chief  of  Engineers  U.S.  Army  1917.  Part  3.  US  Army  Corps 

of  Engineers.  Government  Printing  Office:  Washington,  DC. 


73 


City  Comptroller.  1886.  “Financial  Report  of  the  City  Comptroller  of  the  City  of  St.  Paul 
from  January  1 , 1881  to  January  1 , 1882”  in  St.  Paul  Daily  Globe  1886,  1 1 May. 

. 1 904.  Thirteenth  Annual  Report  of  the  City  Comptroller  of  the  City  of  St.  Paul  for 

the  Fiscal  Year  Ending  December  31,  A.D.  1903.  Pioneer  Press  Company:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

City  of  St.  Paul.  1902.  Annual  Reports  of  the  City  Officers  and  City  Boards  of  the  City  of 
St.  Paul  for  the  Year  Ending  Dec.  31,  1901.  The  Pioneer  Press  Company:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

. 1915,  Proceedings  of  the  Common  Council  of  the  City  of  St.  Paul,  Ramsey 

County,  Minnesota  1915.  Review  Publishing  Co.:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Clark,  Florence  L.  1922.  “Dr.  Mayo’s  Yacht,  ‘North  Star’”  in  Motor  Boat,  10  November, 
Volume  XIX,  No.  21:  25. 

Cokato  Enterprise.  1948,  8 April;  1949,  7 April;  1955a,  17  March;  1955b,  14  April. 

Cokato  Museum.  Cokato  Boat  Works  Outboard  Motor  Boat.  Accession  File.  Cokato 
Museum:  Cokato,  MN. 

Cole,  H.  1910.  “Among  the  Lakes  of  Minnesota”  in  Power  Boating,  July  Volume  VI,  No. 
VII:  377-381. 

Collins,  Paul.  2008.  “The  Oddball  Know-It-All”  in  The  New  York  Times,  5 December. 

Commissioner  of  Public  Works.  1931.  Annual  Report  of  the  Commissioner  of  Public 
Works  of  the  City  of  Saint  Paul.  Pioneer  Press  Co.:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Copyright  Office.  1957.  Catalog  of  Copyright  Entries:  Books  and  Pamphlets  Including 
Serials  and  Contributions  to  Periodicals,  July-December  1956.  Third  Series:  Vol. 
10,  Part  1,  Number  2.  Library  of  Congress:  Washington,  DC. 

Daily  Gate  City.  Keokuk,  IA.  1908,  19  November. 

Daily  Missoulian.  Missoula,  MT.  1914,  30  April. 

Desmond,  Kevin.  2004.  Race  Against  the  Odds:  The  Tragic  Success  Story  of  Miss 
England  II.  Sigma  Press:  Wilmslow,  Cheshire,  UK. 

Devils  Lake  Inter-Ocean  & Devils  Lake  Free  Press.  Devils  Lake,  ND.  1908,  10  July. 

Dillon,  W.  R.  1928.  “Motor  Boats  Protect  Water  Fowl”  in  Motor  Boating,  May,  18-19, 
130. 

Divine,  Mary.  2008.  “Beached  Boat  Gets  Heave-Ho  from  Back  Yard”  in  Pioneer  Press, 
30  April. 


74 


Ellis,  S.  E.  1906.  Picturesque  Minnetonka.  S.  E.  Ellis:  Minneapolis,  MN. 

Evening  Tribune.  Albert  Lea,  MN.  1908,  16  November;  1942,  23  October. 

Fishman,  Joanne  A.  1989.  The  Guide  to  High  Performance  Powerboating:  From 
Racecourse  to  High-Speed  Pleasure  Boat.  Hearst  Marine  Books:  New  York,  NY. 

Fore  ‘N’  Aft.  1907a,  July;  1907b,  September. 

Fox,  Joseph  P.  1943.  Patent  2318213.  https://www.google.com/patents/US2318213 
Grand  Forks  Daily  Herald.  Grand  Forks,  ND.  1916,  19  June. 

Hennepin  County  Herald.  1919,  18  September. 

Herter’s,  Inc.  1949.  Decoys  and  Game  Call,  Special  Paints,  Cements,  Push  Pole 
Heads,  Boat  and  Decoy  Make  Supplies  and  Equipment.  Wholesale  Catalog  No. 
84.  Herter’s,  Inc.:  Waseca,  MN. 

. 1951.  Decoys,  Game  Calls,  Vari-Chokes,  Boat  and  Decoy  Making  Equipment. 

Wholesale  Catalog  No.  86.  Herter’s,  Inc.:  Waseca,  MN. 

. 1956.  Why  You  Should  Use  Herter’s  Chrome  Fiberglas  Process  for  Boat 

Covering,  Repairing  or  Building.  Herter’s,  Inc.:  Waseca,  MN. 

. 1969.  Herter’s  Boats:  World  Famous  Chrome  Fiberglas.  Herter’s,  Inc.:  Waseca, 

MN. 

Hopkins,  G.M.  1916.  Plat  Book  of  the  City  of  Saint  Paul,  Minn.  G.M.  Hopkins  and 
Company:  Philadelphia,  PA. 

Jenkinson,  Thomas,  and  Norene  Roberts.  1985.  Ellen  Ruth  National  Register  of  Historic 
Places  Nomination.  Historical  Research,  Inc.:  Minneapolis,  MN. 

John  R.  Borchert  Map  Library.  University  of  Minnesota:  Minneapolis,  MN. 

Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works.  ND.  Designers  and  Builders  of  All  Kinds  of  Pleasure  Craft: 
Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works.  Joseph  Dingle  Boat  Works:  St.  Pau,  MN. 

Judson,  Jr.,  Edmund  L.  1920.  “Odds  and  Ends  of  Show  Gossip”  in  Motor  Boat,  25 
December,  Vol.  XVII,  No.  24. 

Kegg,  Maude.  1991.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  Oral  History  Project.  Transcript. 
Interviewed  by  Anthony  Godfrey.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Knauff,  Don.  ND.  Herters  1956-1961  Fiberglass  Runabouts.  On  file  at  the  Waseca 
County  Historical  Society:  Waseca,  MN. 


Lake  Breeze,  5 May  1888a;  26  May  1888b;  1 June  1888c. 


75 


Legeros,  Michael  J.  2013.  Historic  and  Former  St.  Paul  Firehouses. 

http://legeros.com/history/st-paul/ 

Marine  News.  1946,  Volume  33. 

Maxwell,  George  Earl.  1953.  Patent  2743696  A.  https://www.google.com/patents/ 
US2743696 

McGinnins,  Scott.  2010.  A Directory  of  Old  Boats.  Scott  D.  McGinnis:  Chaska,  MN. 

Mecum  Auctions.  2010a.  The  Warner  Collection:  The  Awakening  of  an  American 
Treasure.  Mecum  Auctions:  Marengo,  IL. 

. 2010b.  “Warner  Collection:  Vintage  Wooden  Boat  Event  Nets  Nearly  $4  Million” 

in  Mecum  Monthly.  November:  4-5. 

Merjanian,  Peggy.  ND.  The  Story  of  the  Glengarry,  http://acbs-bslol.com/boating- 
history/porthole/glengarry/ 

Merriman,  Ann,  and  Christopher  Olson.  2015.  Lake  Minnetonka  Nautical  Archaeology  5 
Project  Report.  Maritime  Heritage  Minnesota:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 2016.  Lake  Minnetonka  Nautical  Archaeology  6 Project  Report.  Maritime 

Heritage  Minnesota:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Mille  Lacs  Messenger.  1929,  9 May;  1933a,  9 March;  1933b,  18  May;  1933c,  8 June; 
1938,  7 April;  2013,  6 March. 

Miller,  Kristen.  2008.  “Back  into  One  Piece:  More  Than  50  Years  Later,  a Rare  Cokato 
Boat  Works  Boat  Resurfaces”  in  Enterprise  Dispatch,  14  July. 

Minneapolis  Journal.  1902a,  22  February;  1902b,  5 March;  1902c,  23  June;  1902d,  28 
July;  1904a,  14  June;  1904b,  17  June;  1905a,  31  May;  1905b,  3 June;  1905c,  30 
June;  1905d,  11  July;  1905e,  4 August;  1905f,  5 September. 

Minneapolis  Times.  1896,  24  May. 

Minneapolis  Tribune.  1889,  12  May;  1902a,  29  April;  1902b,  27  July;  1905,  4 June; 
1909,  15  August. 

Minnesota  Historical  Society.  Photograph  Collection.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

. Timeline.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Museum  and  Trading  Post,  http://sites.mnhs.org/ 

historic-sites/mille-lacs-indian-museum/timeline 

. Finding  Aid.  Harry  D.  Ayer  and  Family  Papers.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St. 

Paul,  MN. 


76 


. 1988.  Herter’s  St.  Lawrence  Model,  1988.338. 1.A-C.  Accession  Information.  On 

file  at  the  Minnesota  Historical  Society,  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Minnesota,  Ramsey  County.  1895.  Inhabitants  in  the  City  of  St.  Paul,  County  of 
Ramsey.  State  Census  Index:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1905.  Fifth  Decennial  Census  of  Minnesota  Population  Schedule.  State  Census 

Index:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Minnesota  Resources  Commission.  1941.  Directory  of  Minnesota  Manufacturers 
Classified  by  Industry  and  By  County.  Minnesota  Resources  Commission:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

. 1946.  Guide  Book  to  Minnesota  Industry:  Q Directory  of  Minnesota 

Manufacturers  Classified  by  Industry  and  By  Community  Location.  Minnesota 
Resources  Commission:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Minnetonka  Herald.  1954,12  August. 

Minnetonka  Record.  1905,  2 June. 

Miron,  Molly.  2007.  “Roamer  Has  Plied  Cass  Lake  for  87  Years”  in  Bemidji  Pioneer,  14 
July. 

Mitchell,  Sally.  1991.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  Oral  History  Project.  Transcript. 
Interviewed  by  Anthony  Godfrey.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Moorhead  Daily  News.  1942,  22  October;  1943,  5 April. 

Motor  Age.  1905,  22  June. 

Motor  Boat.  1907a  10  May;  1907b,  25  May;  1908,  25  December;  1909a,  10  July;  1909b, 
25  July;  1909c,  10  August;  1920,  25  November;  1952,  August. 

Motor  Boating.  1922,  December;  1923,  October;  1933,  June;  1934  February;  1935  July; 
1952a,  July;  1952b,  August;  1954,  January. 

Motoring  and  Boating.  1905,  1 1 May. 

Mott,  Henry  A.  1894.  Yachts  and  Yachtsmen  of  America.  Volume  1.  International  Yacht 
Publishing  Company:  New  York,  NY. 

Naval  History  Division.  1976.  Dictionary  of  American  Naval  Fighting  Ships.  Volume  VI. 
Department  of  the  Navy:  Washington,  DC. 

Neuzil,  Mark.  2004.  Passion  for  the  River:  Mayo  and  the  Mississippi.  Mayo  Foundation 
for  Medical  Education  and  Research:  Rochester,  MN. 

Northwestern  Tourist.  1889,  18  May;  1890,  5 July. 


77 


Open  Exhaust.  1915a,  10  June;  1915b,  10  September;  1915c,  10  November;  1916,  10 
February;  1917a,  10  February;  1917b  June. 

Pacific  Motor  Boat.  1920  January,  Volume  12,  No.  4. 

Polk,  Ralph  L.  and  Jacob  W.  Weeks.  1879.  St.  Paul  City  Directory  1879-80.  R.L.  Polk  & 
Co.  and  A.C.  Danser:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Polk,  Ralph  L.  1914.  R.L.  Polk  & Co.’s  St.  Paul  City  Directory  1914.  Vol.  L.  R.L.  Polk  & 
Co.  Publishers:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Popular  Science.  1957,  March;  1959,  January. 

Power  Boat  News.  1905a,  29  April;  1905b,  13  May. 

Power  Boating.  1910a  January;  1910b  June;  1914  January;  1916  August. 

Ramaley  Boat  Company.  ~1911.  Ramaley  Boats.  Ramaley  Boat  Company:  White  Bear 
Lake,  MN. 

. ~1 91 3.  Ramaley  Row  Boats.  Ramaley  Boat  Company:  Wayzata,  MN. 

Railway  Signaling  and  Communications.  1927,  March,  Volume  20,  No.  3. 

Ramsey  County.  1928.  Financial  Statement  of  Ramsey  County,  Minnesota:  For  the 
Fiscal  Year  Ending  February  28.  Ramsey  County:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

Research  Division.  1949.  Directory  of  Minnesota  Manufacturers  and  Guide  Book  to 
Minnesota  Industry.  Minnesota  Department  of  Research  and  Development:  St. 
Paul,  MN. 

. 1952.  1952  Directory  of  Minnesota  Manufacturers.  Minnesota  Department  of 

Business  Research  and  Development:  St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1955.  Minnesota  Directory  of  Manufacturers  1955:  A Listing  of  Minnesota-Made 

Products  and  Their  Producers.  Minnesota  Department  of  Business  Development: 
St.  Paul,  MN. 

. 1957.  Minnesota  Directory  of  Manufacturers  1957:  A Listing  of  Minnesota-Made 

Products  and  Their  Producers.  Minnesota  Department  of  Business  Development: 
St.  Paul,  MN. 

Republican  Herald.  Winona,  MN.  1951, 22  September. 

Rock  Island  Argus.  1912,  30  September;  1914,  25  September. 

The  Rudder.  1909,  September;  1947,  March. 


78 


Sables,  Robert  P.  2005.  The  Story  of  USS  SCz1_024-  NavSource. 
http://www.  navsou  rce.org/arch  ives  / 12/151 024d . htm 

Sam,  Batiste.  1991.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Trading  Post  Oral  History  Project.  Transcript. 
Interviewed  by  Anthony  Godfrey.  Minnesota  Historical  Society:  St.  Paul,  MN 

Sanborn  Map  Company.  1904.  Insurance  Maps  of  St.  Paul,  Minnesota.  Sanborn  Map 
Company:  New  York,  NY. 

. 1912.  Insurance  Maps  of  Wayzata,  Minnesota.  Sanborn  Map  Company:  New 

York,  NY. 

Schley,  Tom.  2001.  “Mahogany  Bay:  The  House  that  Todd  Built”  in  Antique  & Classic 
Boat  Magazine.  November-December:  15-28. 

Smith,  Doug.  2015.  “Herter’s  Catalog  is  Long  Gone,  But  Not  Forgotten”  in  Star  Tribune, 
7 February. 

Sommers,  Laura.  2000.  American  Dreamboats:  An  Illustrated  History  of  Larson  Boats  - 
the  Company,  the  Boats,  and  the  Times  1913-2000.  Larson  Boats:  Little  Falls, 
MN. 

St.  Paul  Globe.  1900a,  9 May;  1900b,  4 December;  1902,  27  April;  1904a,  1 May; 
1904b,  19  June. 

St.  Paul  Daily  Globe.  1880,  5 March;  1881,  29  April;  1883,  14  July;  1884a,  18  March 
1884b,  12  September;  1884c,  31  December;  1885a,  31  January;  1885b,  10 
June;  1888a,  2 February;  1888b  17  May;  1889,  16  June;  1890a,  19  April;  1890b, 
24  July;  1890c,  28  July;  1891a,  26  April;  1891b,  18  May;  1891c,  31  May;  1891d, 
12  July;  1892a,  17  April;  1892b,  15  May;  1892c,  29  May;  1892d,  19  June;  1892e, 
3 July;  1892f,  14  August;  1892g,  21  August;  1892h,  28  August;  1892i,  4 
September;  1893a,  29  May;  1893b,  6 June;  1893c,  25  June;  1893d,  2 July; 
1893e,  6 August;  1893f,  27  August,  1893g,  28  August;  1893h,  10  September; 
1894a,  29  May;  1894b,  31  May;  1894c,  8 July;  1894d,  22  July;  1894e,  29  July; 
1894f,  19  August;  1895a,  12  May;  1895b,  31  May;  1895c,  25  August;  1895d,  29 
August;  1895e,  8 September. 

Steel.  1934,  Volume  95. 

Vadnais,  Cynthia.  2004.  Looking  Back  at  White  Bear  Lake  - A Pictorial  History  of  the 
White  Bear  Lake  Area.  White  Bear  Stereoptics  Company:  White  Bear,  MN. 

Waterways  Journal.  1975,  24  May;  1996,  6 May. 

Waymarking.  2013.  Mille  Lacs  Indian  Boat  Works.  MNHS  Historical  Marker. 
http://www.waymarking.com/waymarks/WMJK3B_Mille_Lacs_lndian_Boat_Work 
s_Vineland_MN 

Wayzata  Reporter.  1912,  14  November. 


79 


West  Hennepin  History  Center.  Photograph  Collection.  West  Hennepin  History  Center: 
Long  Lake,  MN. 

White  Bear  Life,  23  March  1900;  18  January  1901a;  17  May  1901b. 

Willmar  Tribune.  1916,  26  April. 

Woodyboater.  2013.  Classic  Minnesota  Part  2:  Glengarry,  Celebrating  75  Years  of 
Service  on  the  St.  Croix  River,  http://www.woodyboater.com/blog/2013/08/23/ 
classic-minnesota-part-2-glengarry-celebrating-75-years-of-service-on-the-st- 
croix-river/